When Trust Goes Bad: Church Treasurer Arrested for Allegedly Stealing Over $70,000
Here are the facts about what happened:
- Marisa Humose, 48, the former treasurer for Greater Mount Pleasant Missionary Baptist Church, was arrested on November 3rd, facing charges of grand theft and fraud.
- She is accused of stealing over $70,000 from the church’s Cash App account between 2022 and June 2025.
- The church’s pastor first reported suspected financial problems in June after noticing unauthorized transfers, and Humose was also terminated from her state job on the day of her arrest due to a separate investigation.
This kind of story really hits home for small churches and everyday families. Many small churches operate on tight budgets, relying entirely on the faithful giving of their members. Every dollar is precious. When someone in a position of deep trust, especially a treasurer, allegedly abuses that trust and steals from the offering, it’s not just a financial hit; it’s a spiritual wound. It makes people question where their tithes are going and can make others hesitant to give, which directly impacts the church’s ability to do ministry. For families, it’s a stark reminder that even within trusted circles, vigilance is needed. We need to be good stewards of our own money, and of the funds we entrust to our churches, making sure there are clear processes and accountability, especially with digital tools like Cash App that can make it too easy for bad actors if not managed carefully. It’s about protecting the Lord’s work and the integrity of the Body of Christ.
This story was analyzed for Christ P2P. You can read the original reporting here: https://www.tallahassee.com/story/news/local/2025/11/04/tallahassee-church-treasurer-arrested-in-70000-fraud-case-greater-mount-pleasant-baptist-church/87092445007/
‘
