Highland Park UMC Releases Statement on Legal Dispute with United Methodist Church

Highland Park United Methodist Church has released a statement addressing the legal dispute with the United Methodist Church, detailing its rationale for revising its governing documents. The revisions, at the center of the lawsuit, were made to align the church’s corporate bylaws with legal guidance from the Texas Supreme Court. The court had clarified that religious terms or doctrinal rules embedded in corporate documents would not be accepted by courts, emphasizing the need for corporate papers to be secular in nature.

The lawsuit, filed by the regional United Methodist Church, alleges that Highland Park UMC attempted to sever ties with the denomination four years ago without proper communication. The church has denied these claims, stating that it remained part of the denomination in 2022, a time when over 7,600 churches left the United Methodist Church. The church leadership emphasized its commitment to the denomination and its desire to maintain religious and ecclesiastical connections.

Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. of the Horizon Texas Conference addressed the congregation in a video message, noting that the decision to pursue legal action was not made lightly. He reiterated that Jesus Christ is the head of the church, not any individual leader or governing body. Saenz acknowledged the uncertainty within the denomination during this period, including ongoing legal disputes involving institutions like Southern Methodist University, which is a historic partner of the church.

Highland Park UMC’s statement highlights the need for legal protection for its congregation amid the broader challenges facing the denomination. The church asserts that its actions were driven by a desire to ensure compliance with legal standards while preserving its religious identity. The revisions to its governing documents were intended to safeguard the church’s legal standing, particularly in light of the Texas Supreme Court’s guidance.

The Horizon Texas Conference has not commented on Highland Park UMC’s statement. The legal proceedings continue as both parties present their perspectives on the matter. The case raises broader questions about the balance between religious autonomy and legal compliance within the United Methodist Church.

The situation underscores the complexities of navigating legal and ecclesiastical structures within a denomination facing significant internal and external challenges. As the case unfolds, the focus remains on the legal and administrative decisions made by Highland Park UMC, with implications for the broader United Methodist community. The church’s actions reflect a commitment to protecting its congregation while maintaining its ties to the denomination.

Source: Read the original report