Hyannis Homeless Shelter Considers Appeal After Zoning Board Blocks Building Permit

The St. Joseph House homeless shelter in Hyannis, operated by Catholic Charities, is evaluating its next steps after the Barnstable Zoning Board of Appeals denied its application to relocate to a new site. The proposed location, 460 West Main St., was initially granted a building permit, but the board overturned that decision. The shelter currently operates at 77 Winter St., about two miles east of the new site.

Opponents of the relocation raised concerns about neighborhood safety and questioned whether the shelter qualifies for the state’s Dover Amendment. This law provides religious exemptions from local zoning regulations, and Catholic Charities, which runs the shelter, is a faith-based organization. The board’s decision came after a challenge to the permit, which had been issued under the amendment’s provisions.

James Kupfer, director of planning and development for Barnstable, noted that the Dover Amendment does allow for some religious exemptions. However, he emphasized that the board’s role was to review and challenge the permit’s validity. “The status or designation was challenged,” he said, highlighting the legal complexity surrounding the case.

In response to community concerns, Catholic Charities and the shelter’s landlord, Housing Assistance, reached out to parents at Hyannis West Elementary School, which is near the proposed site. The organizations stated in an email that their relocation plan aligns with both the letter and spirit of the Dover Amendment. They affirmed their commitment to serving the community and are now assessing their available options.

The situation underscores the ongoing tension between local zoning laws and the needs of vulnerable populations. As the shelter explores potential appeals or alternative solutions, the broader conversation about housing insecurity and the role of faith-based organizations in addressing it continues. Proverbs 31:8-9 reminds us to speak up for those who cannot speak for themselves, a call that resonates in the struggle to provide safe and dignified shelter for all.

Source: Read the original report