Clergy Sex Abuse Claimants Plan to Appeal Settlement Assessments: Survivors Express Frustration with Evaluation Process and Payment Caps in Archdiocese of New Orleans Case

In a recent development, some claimants in a multimillion-dollar bankruptcy settlement involving the Archdiocese of New Orleans have expressed intentions to appeal their settlement assessments. Johnny Krummel, a survivor of sexual abuse at Hope Haven and Madonna Manor Orphanage, shared his perspective on the matter. Despite being informed of a potential $500,000 payment, Krummel emphasized that his primary desire was for a day in court, underscoring the inadequacy of the settlement in addressing the gravity of the abuse he endured.

Aaron Hebert, another claimant and a survivor of abuse by former priest Lawrence Hecker, echoed similar sentiments. He described the claims review process as dehumanizing, highlighting the use of a point system to determine compensation. This system, which assigns points based on the severity of abuse, has been criticized by survivors for its perceived inadequacies. For instance, Hebert noted that a fellow survivor who was raped received only 75 points, despite the severity of the crime, which he deemed unjust.

The point system has led to varied assessments among survivors, with Hebert receiving 56 points and Krummel 85. Both survivors argue that the cap on individual payments at approximately $640,000 is insufficient, especially when compared to potential outcomes in state court. Hebert pointed out that similar cases in state court have resulted in significantly higher settlements, suggesting that the bankruptcy process may not have served the survivors’ interests adequately.

The frustrations of Hebert and Krummel reflect broader concerns among survivors about the fairness and transparency of the settlement process. As they prepare to appeal their assessments, their actions underscore a collective call for justice and accountability, resonating with the biblical principle of seeking justice and mercy, as highlighted in Micah 6:8. This ongoing legal and moral struggle serves as a reminder of the importance of upholding truth and care for victims, aligning with the broader Christian values of justice and compassion.

Source: Read the original report