A Disturbing Pattern of Sexual Abuse Emerges Among Former Members of the Old Apostolic Lutheran Church

The story of two sisters, now in their 50s, reveals a troubling pattern of sexual abuse that spans generations. Both women, who grew up in South Dakota and Washington state, were sexually abused by older brothers during their early years. They later became abusers themselves, targeting younger relatives. Their experiences are part of a broader narrative uncovered by ProPublica, which interviewed 20 former members of the Old Apostolic Lutheran Church. These individuals describe a culture where sexual abuse was normalized, extending across North America and multiple generations of church members.

The former members report that the church often urged them to “forgive and forget” rather than report abuse to authorities. This approach, they say, contributed to a cycle of harm. Experts, including former prosecutor Victor Vieth, emphasize that such a culture can lead to long-term consequences, including the perpetuation of abusive behavior. Vieth, who now trains child-abuse investigators, notes that failing to address abuse through repentance and accountability can foster sexual behavior problems in children, including instances of sexual assault.

The Old Apostolic Lutheran Church in the U.S. and Canada has responded to these allegations, stating that they do not believe abuse is more prevalent within their congregation than in the general population. However, the experiences of the former members suggest otherwise. The church’s leadership has not publicly acknowledged the systemic issues raised by the victims, nor have they provided detailed responses to the claims of a normalized culture of abuse.

One of the sisters has made an effort to reconcile with the younger brother she abused, demonstrating a desire for healing and accountability. This personal journey highlights the complex emotional and moral challenges faced by those who have been part of such a culture. It also underscores the importance of addressing abuse with compassion and justice, rather than dismissing it through forgiveness alone.

The case of these two sisters and others like them raises important questions about the role of religious institutions in protecting children and promoting accountability. The normalization of abuse within the Old Apostolic Lutheran Church, as described by former members, suggests a failure to uphold the principles of justice and care that should guide any community. The story serves as a reminder of the need for transparency, repentance, and a commitment to preventing harm.

The experiences of these individuals reflect a broader issue within some religious groups, where the prioritization of forgiveness over justice can enable cycles of abuse. The church’s response to these allegations has been limited, and there is a clear need for more comprehensive investigations and reforms. The story of these two sisters, and the others who have spoken out, highlights the urgent need for accountability and a commitment to protecting the vulnerable.

Source: Read the original report