Former Priest Accused of Embezzling Over $740,000 from Churches and Family

Gregory Allen Medley, 69, a former Catholic priest from Pennsylvania, is accused of embezzling funds from three churches, community groups, and the Knights of Columbus organization. Investigators allege that Medley misappropriated nearly $320,000 over several years, using the money for personal expenses such as vacations, drugs, and a Ford Mustang valued at over $35,000. The allegations, which began as early as 2018, led to his arrest on August 14 in Vero Beach, Florida, and subsequent transfer to Pennsylvania for prosecution.

Medley served at a church in the Drayton area until his suspension in February 2024. His financial management role included overseeing the financial affairs of his elderly mother, who was unable to manage her own accounts due to illness. Investigators claim he took over $230,000 from his mother’s investment accounts, diverting funds that were intended for her care and support. This exploitation of his mother’s vulnerability is a central part of the case.

Evidence gathered during the investigation included donation envelopes found in Medley’s trash, which suggest he was collecting funds for the church but not properly accounting for them. His electronic devices contained photos of credit cards and bank documents related to church finances, along with communications and images linked to drug use. These findings support the allegations of financial misconduct and personal misuse of church resources.

The case also involves allegations that Medley sold a gold trophy for over $19,000, with the buyer intending the proceeds to benefit the church. However, the money did not reach its intended destination, according to the complaint. This incident highlights the broader pattern of financial mismanagement and the potential harm caused to the church and its community.

In addition to the financial allegations, investigators claim that some of the embezzled funds were used to purchase heroin, which Medley allegedly exchanged for sexual favors. This raises concerns about the intersection of financial misconduct and personal vice, underscoring the need for accountability and transparency in church leadership.

The Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office has taken the case seriously, emphasizing the importance of protecting church funds and ensuring that those in positions of trust are held to the highest standards of integrity. The case serves as a reminder of the biblical call to pursue justice and care for the vulnerable, as seen in Proverbs 31:8-9, which urges the defense of the oppressed and the advocacy for the poor.

As the legal proceedings unfold, the focus remains on the facts and the responsibility of those entrusted with church resources. The case reflects the necessity of vigilance, accountability, and the pursuit of justice, aligning with the principles of Micah 6:8, which calls for actions rooted in mercy, justice, and humility.

Source: Read the original report (translated from Hebrew)