PSNI had intelligence on Donaldson abuse before victim named him

The Presbyterian Church in Ireland (PCI) has been implicated in a controversy surrounding the handling of a sex abuse allegation against former Northern Ireland politician Jeffrey Donaldson. According to a BBC investigation, a detective chief inspector and a child safeguarding expert from the PCI identified Donaldson as a potential abuser during a meeting with a victim, known as Complainant A, in March 2023. The victim did not name Donaldson at that time, but the two professionals believed she was describing him.

Dr Jacqui Montgomery-Devlin, the PCI’s head of safeguarding at the time, later told BBC NI’s Spotlight programme that she and the detective chief inspector were convinced the woman was referring to Donaldson. She noted that the victim described the abuser as a “high profile” individual, which led to the identification. Montgomery-Devlin said she informed the detective chief inspector of her belief, and she was later confirmed to be correct.

The case has raised questions about the PCI’s role in the process and the handling of sensitive information. A former senior police officer, Norman Baxter, has suggested that the suspicion of Donaldson’s involvement should have prompted immediate action within the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI). Baxter argued that such information would constitute “intelligence” indicating a potential abuse allegation against a high-profile individual with access to vulnerable groups.

Donaldson, who was found guilty of 18 sex abuse charges earlier this month, is currently awaiting sentence. The PSNI has declined to comment on the matter, citing ongoing legal proceedings. The case highlights the complex interplay between church and state in addressing abuse allegations and the responsibilities of institutions to act on credible suspicions.

The situation underscores the importance of transparency and accountability in both religious and governmental bodies. As Proverbs 18:17 states, “The first to present his case seems right, until another comes forward and examines him.” This biblical principle calls for careful examination and responsible action when dealing with allegations of abuse, ensuring that justice is pursued with integrity and compassion.

Source: Read the original report