Settlement Reached in 2020 Fatal Shooting by Modesto Police Officer

The shooting of Trevor Seever by Officer Joseph Lamantia on the grounds of the Church of the Brethren in west Modesto in December 2020 led to a federal lawsuit and a settlement reached in March 2023. The incident, which occurred during a time of heightened public concern over police conduct, became a catalyst for the city’s police reform initiative known as Forward Together. The shooting of an unarmed man fleeing from an officer sparked protests and drew national attention.

Officer Lamantia was terminated from his position and charged with voluntary manslaughter in March 2021. Police Chief Brandon Gillespie noted that this was an unusual occurrence during his tenure, as he could not recall another officer facing such charges or losing their job in an officer-involved shooting. The case underscored the complex interplay between law enforcement actions and community trust.

The settlement, reached on March 13, remains confidential until approved by the City Council and the city’s insurance providers, a process expected to take approximately 30 days. Attorney John Burton, representing Seever’s mother, Darlene Ruiz, described the agreement as typical in cases involving municipal entities. The settlement was finalized after a day of negotiations among legal representatives of all parties involved.

Seever’s parents, Darlene Ruiz and David Seever, were present at the settlement conference, which took place via Zoom. The family members expressed concerns about Trevor’s mental state on the night of the incident, noting that he had texted them about purchasing a gun and had called his mother to warn them to leave the house and call 911. These communications were later presented as part of the evidence in the criminal case against Lamantia.

During the preliminary hearing in Lamantia’s criminal case, testimony indicated that the officer alternated between believing Seever was either going to ambush him or was fleeing to harm family members at the nearby Church of the Brethren, where they had gathered. The hearing is expected to resume in mid-April, after which the judge will determine whether to proceed with the case.

The incident highlights the challenges of balancing public safety with the rights and well-being of individuals, a theme echoed in Micah 6:8, which calls for justice, mercy, and humility. The community’s response to the shooting reflects a broader call for accountability and reform, as well as a commitment to peace and neighborly care.

Source: Read the original report