Holy Apostles Parish Assessment Appeal Upheld by Vatican, Reversing Diocesan Decree

In a significant development, Holy Apostles Parish has successfully overturned its financial assessment intended to contribute to the Diocese of Buffalo’s $150 million settlement with child sex abuse survivors. This decision by the Dicastery for Clergy, a Vatican body, has reversed Bishop Michael Fisher’s decree, mandating the return of any funds already transferred to the diocese back to the parish.

The assessment, initially announced in the summer of 2025, required Holy Apostles to contribute $1.3 million, representing 80% of its unrestricted cash and assets. This was part of a broader strategy to allocate funds from parishes scheduled for closure or merger to support the diocese’s settlement obligations. However, the Dicastery for Clergy determined that the diocese did not adhere to the proper procedures outlined in Canon Law, leading to the appeal’s success.

The ruling highlighted several critical issues, including the assessment amount exceeding what Canon Law permits, even when considering the potential for parish administrators to gift money. The diocese’s communications suggested that these payments were mandatory, contradicting the notion of them being voluntary gifts. Furthermore, the Dicastery for Clergy emphasized that any tribute imposed by a bishop must be justified by grave reasons, adhere to a specified process, and remain moderate and proportionate. The ruling found no evidence supporting that the assessment met these criteria, nor did Bishop Fisher follow the necessary procedures.

Additionally, the transfer of funds to the St. Joseph Fund was scrutinized. The Dicastery for Clergy concluded that this action did not comply with Canon Law, as it effectively removed the money from the parish’s control, preventing its use for necessary expenses. This transfer also violated procedural requirements, further invalidating the assessment.

This decision aligns with a series of similar rulings by the Dicastery for Clergy, including recent announcements affecting other parishes, such as St. Brendan on the Lake in Newfane. Earlier this year, eight Catholic parishes in Western New York were similarly relieved from contributing to the diocese’s bankruptcy settlement following a Vatican ruling.

In navigating these complex legal and moral issues, the church is reminded of its call to uphold justice and mercy, as encapsulated in Micah 6:8. The pursuit of accountability, while maintaining care for victims and the community, remains paramount. This case underscores the importance of adhering to established legal and ethical standards, ensuring that actions taken are just, transparent, and in line with both civil and ecclesiastical law.

Source: Read the original report