Cardinal Cupich and Two Catholic Nun Orders Sue to Block Illinois Medical Aid-in-Dying Law

Chicago Archbishop Cardinal Blase Cupich and two orders of Catholic nuns have filed a lawsuit to block an Illinois medical aid-in-dying law set to take effect on September 12. The law, signed by Governor JB Pritzker late last year, allows terminally ill adults aged 18 and older with a prognosis of less than six months to live to request life-ending medication they administer themselves. Illinois would become the 12th state to permit medical aid in dying.

Cupich, along with the Sisters of Charity of the Blessed Virgin Mary and the Dominican Sisters of Hawthorne, argue the law violates constitutional protections for free speech and religious freedom. The archdiocese claims the law compels doctors to provide information about assisted dying and its benefits, which they say forces healthcare professionals to act against their faith.

The law requires two doctors to diagnose a patient’s terminal illness and includes a psychological evaluation to ensure the patient is of sound mind. Both oral and written requests are needed to prevent coercion. Ed Yohnka of the American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois noted there are extensive guardrails in the legislation.

The ACLU of Illinois disputes the archdiocese’s interpretation, stating doctors are not required to mention the option but must acknowledge it if a patient asks. If a physician is uncomfortable discussing the assisted-dying option, another physician can step in.

Cupich expressed sympathy for terminally ill patients but believes assisted suicide is not the solution. He stated the medical field understands pain can be managed humanely.

The archdiocese is seeking a temporary restraining order and claims it is confident a judge will grant the request early next week. Supporters of the law argue it provides a compassionate option for those facing unbearable suffering.

Source: Read the original report