First Baptist Orlando churchgoer who sparked controversy with same-sex wedding has died

Joe Mills, a Florida business owner and active member of First Baptist Church Orlando, who sparked controversy within the Southern Baptist Convention by publicly acknowledging a same-sex marriage, has died. He was 68. Mills passed away unexpectedly on April 13, according to an obituary published by Sellars Funeral Home. The obituary highlighted his deep connection to Orlando, where he and his family spent significant time, and his dedication to the First Baptist Church of Orlando, where he was a long-time member and participant.

Mills, who married his longtime partner, Mario, on December 4, 2021, had been a regular attendee at First Baptist Orlando and contributed to the church’s outreach efforts. He was known for his involvement in Bible study groups and various church events, and the obituary noted that he was “well regarded and recognized for his good work” by the congregation. His family described him as someone who found great peace and strength through his faith and community.

In 2023, Mills told The Christian Post that despite regularly attending First Baptist Orlando and paying his tithes, he was never officially recognized as a member by the church. He claimed to have publicly stated his membership on social media, which led to criticism from some Southern Baptists. Casey Butner, senior pastor of Beulah Baptist Church in Winter Garden, Florida, questioned the accuracy of Mills’ claims, suggesting that he was effectively a member in practice, even if not officially on paper.

Butner argued that Mills was participating in the church’s activities and adhering to its teachings in many ways, even though he disagreed with the Southern Baptist Convention’s stance on marriage. He emphasized that true membership involves more than just attendance or financial support—it includes doctrinal alignment and active participation. Butner’s comments reflect a broader debate within the Southern Baptist Convention about the interpretation of membership and doctrinal adherence in the face of personal convictions and public actions.

The controversy surrounding Mills highlights the tensions within the Southern Baptist Convention regarding issues of doctrine, membership, and the role of personal conviction in church life. As the SBC continues to navigate these complex discussions, the case of Joe Mills serves as a reminder of the personal and communal implications of such debates. The story also underscores the importance of transparency and accountability within religious institutions, as well as the need for compassion and understanding in the face of differing beliefs.

Source: Read the original report