Highland Park UMC Sued by United Methodist Church’s Horizon Texas Conference

The United Methodist Church’s Horizon Texas Conference has filed a lawsuit against Highland Park United Methodist Church, alleging that the congregation violated its bylaws by altering governance structures without proper approval. The suit was filed in Dallas County and marks a significant escalation in the dispute between the church and its denomination. The Horizon Texas Conference claims the changes, reportedly made in 2022, removed oversight from the denomination and its members, undermining the church’s accountability to the broader United Methodist structure.

Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr., who leads the Horizon Texas Conference, addressed the issue in a statement, emphasizing that the legal action was not taken lightly. He stated the lawsuit aims to preserve the ability of congregants to worship within the framework they have embraced for over a century. “This lawsuit is not one the Conference brings lightly,” Saenz said, adding that the denomination remains committed to seeking a “faithful path toward restoration and resolution.”

Highland Park UMC’s senior minister, the Rev. Matt Tuggle, responded by asserting that his congregation has always been “faithful United Methodists” and has supported United Methodist leadership. He called the lawsuit “meritless” and expressed disappointment, stating that the church continues to engage with the conference on its allegations while remaining focused on its mission to minister to its congregation.

The conflict highlights tensions between local congregations and denominational authorities, particularly around governance and autonomy. The Horizon Texas Conference has reportedly attempted to address the issue through dialogue, but those efforts have failed. The lawsuit now places the dispute in the hands of the court, with both sides maintaining their positions.

The case raises broader questions about the balance between local church autonomy and denominational oversight. While the United Methodist Church emphasizes a shared faith and communal responsibility, individual congregations often seek the freedom to adapt their practices to local needs. This tension has become increasingly pronounced in recent years, particularly as congregations navigate issues such as social justice, theological diversity, and financial sustainability.

The legal battle between Highland Park UMC and the Horizon Texas Conference reflects a larger pattern within the United Methodist Church, where differing interpretations of doctrine and governance have led to internal divisions. As the lawsuit proceeds, it may serve as a test case for how the denomination handles disputes between local churches and its leadership. The outcome could influence future relationships between congregations and the broader church structure.

In the midst of this legal challenge, both parties have emphasized their commitment to the mission of the church. The Horizon Texas Conference seeks to uphold the traditions and structures that have guided the United Methodist Church for generations, while Highland Park UMC insists on its right to govern itself according to its own discernment. The situation underscores the importance of dialogue, mutual respect, and a shared vision for the future of the church. As the case unfolds, the hope is that the resolution will reflect the values of mercy, justice, and unity that are central to the Christian faith.

Source: Read the original report