Israeli Rabbi Criticizes Zionist Project, Calls for International Administration in Place of State

Rabbi Lando, a prominent leader within the Haridi current, has expressed deep skepticism about the Zionist project and the establishment of the State of Israel. During a meeting with rabbis following the last war, he stated that it would have been better if the State of Israel had not been created, and instead, religious Zionist soldiers had been killed by “distorted Torah teachings.” This sentiment reflects a growing internal division within Israeli society, particularly among right-wing factions, where some question the moral and strategic foundations of the Zionist movement.

Lando’s remarks highlight a broader critique of the Israeli government’s policies, particularly its reliance on religious Zionist soldiers who, according to him, are led by teachings that prioritize the “dignity of the State” over humanitarian principles. He argued that these soldiers are sent into conflict not for rescue but for the sake of national pride, a perspective that contrasts sharply with the goals of international peace and justice. Lando’s influence extends to key political allies, including the “Hudot Hitura” and “Shas” parties, which are part of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition. These parties have historically opposed the recruitment of religious school students, a stance that aligns with Lando’s views.

The Israeli government has faced internal criticism for the actions of settlers, who have justified their behavior as a form of resistance. Foreign Minister Gideon Saar has condemned these actions, warning that they damage Israel’s global image. In response, religious Zionist ministers, such as Strok, have defended settlers, framing them as victims of Palestinian aggression and accusing critics of misrepresenting their cause. This ideological clash underscores the deepening divisions within Israeli society, where differing interpretations of national identity and religious duty are increasingly at odds.

The debate over the Zionist project’s legacy is further complicated by historical context. Lando suggested that Arab hostility toward Jews has been exacerbated by Zionist policies, a claim that challenges the narrative of Jewish self-defense. He argued that the establishment of the State of Israel has led to material and spiritual disasters, a perspective that contrasts with the Zionist vision of salvation. This critique raises important questions about the long-term consequences of political and religious movements, as well as the moral responsibilities of those who lead them.

As tensions continue to rise, the internal and external challenges facing Israel grow more complex. The call for unity within the Israeli government and society is increasingly difficult to achieve, given the stark differences in worldview and priorities. The situation calls for a commitment to justice, mercy, and the pursuit of peace, as emphasized in Micah 6:8, which urges people to act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with God. Such principles remain essential in navigating the moral and political landscape of the region.

Source: Read the original report (translated from Arabic)