The Episcopal Church Discloses Church Discipline Investigations Into Two Presiding Bishop Nominees

The Episcopal Church has disclosed that two of the five bishops under consideration for the role of presiding bishop are currently undergoing church discipline investigations. The denomination shared this information on June 13, as part of an effort to enhance transparency in addressing misconduct allegations against bishops.

Bishop DeDe Duncan-Probe of the Diocese of Central New York and Bishop Daniel Gutiérrez of the Diocese of Pennsylvania are among those under scrutiny. Both, along with Bishop Robert Wright of the Episcopal Diocese of Atlanta, had previous complaints dismissed. The announcement, authored by Presiding Bishop Michael Curry and Vice President of the House of Bishops Mary Gray-Reeves, emphasized the importance of accountability and transparency in leadership.

The disclosure comes just days before the General Convention in Louisville, Kentucky, where the next presiding bishop will be elected. The statement acknowledged the call for greater transparency from clergy and laypeople, reflecting the denomination’s commitment to being a safe place for all.

Title IV of the Episcopal Church’s bylaws outlines the process for addressing misconduct allegations against clergy, including bishops. This includes violations of church bylaws, failure to cooperate with investigations, safeguarding church property, and acts of sexual misconduct, among other offenses. The process is designed to ensure accountability while balancing confidentiality and transparency.

From August 2023 to February 2024, 34 complaints about bishop misconduct were reported to the Title IV intake officer. Of these, seven were dismissed, nine were referred for further investigation, and 18 remained in the initial inquiry stage. Since then, some cases have advanced in the Title IV process as new allegations have emerged.

Among the current nominees, Bishop Duncan-Probe faced an anonymous report in early May alleging she misrepresented her academic credentials. The matter was referred for investigation later that month. The details of other allegations against the nominees have not been fully disclosed, but the church has committed to addressing these matters with due process.

The Episcopal Church’s response to misconduct allegations reflects a broader commitment to justice and accountability, rooted in the belief that leadership carries a heightened responsibility. As the denomination moves toward the election of its next presiding bishop, the process underscores the importance of integrity and transparency in governance. Micah 6:8 reminds us that what God desires is to act justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with Him—a principle that should guide all aspects of church leadership.

Source: Read the original report