Wesleyan Church Closes After Pastor Finds Romans 9 Scripture

Dale Irwin, pastor of Romulus Wesleyan Church in New York, announced the closure of his congregation after discovering Chapter 9 of the Book of Romans. Irwin explained that he had been preparing for Sunday’s sermon, titled “Choose To Elect Yourself,” when he accidentally flipped to the chapter. He described being “visibly shaken” by the content and stated that the discovery left him with no choice but to close the church.

Irwin, who had previously been taught that Romans 9 was a “Puritan fairy tale,” admitted he read the chapter and was left speechless. He expressed that the revelation was so profound that it rendered the church’s continued operation impossible. “Welp, what can I say? That’s it. We had a good run,” he said, hinting at a possible future affiliation with another denomination or theological tradition.

The incident has sparked discussion within Wesleyan-Holiness churches, which emphasize sanctification and the assurance of salvation. While the Wesleyan Church’s teachings typically focus on the doctrine of prevenient grace and the possibility of falling from grace, the discovery of Romans 9 has raised questions about the church’s interpretation of divine election and human responsibility.

Romans 9 is a complex passage that addresses God’s sovereignty in salvation and the mystery of His choices. It challenges believers to grapple with the tension between divine will and human free will. For Irwin, the chapter’s content was so unsettling that it led to the dissolution of his congregation, highlighting the profound impact such theological revelations can have on a pastor’s ministry and decisions.

The closure of Romulus Wesleyan Church serves as a reminder of the weight of Scripture and the potential for doctrinal discoveries to reshape a congregation’s trajectory. While the Wesleyan Church and related denominations emphasize the importance of personal faith and sanctification, this case illustrates how a single passage can lead to significant and unexpected consequences.

Source: Read the original report