Vatican upholds closure of Mother of Sorrows Church in Ashtabula, Ohio

The Vatican has affirmed the decision of Bishop David Bonnar of the Catholic Diocese of Youngstown to relegate Mother of Sorrows Church in Ashtabula, Ohio, to profane but not sordid use. This ruling, issued by the Discastery for Clergy in Rome, aligns with Bishop Bonnar’s earlier decree from October 2025, which marked the formal closure of the church. The decision was communicated through a press release from the diocese.

The closure was necessitated by several challenges, including a shortage of priests, a declining parishioner population, and the aging condition of the church’s buildings. Monsignor John Zuraw of the diocese explained that these factors prompted the need for the church to be repurposed for everyday use rather than continued religious function.

Local parishioners expressed concern over the closure, viewing the church as a significant part of their community and heritage. In December 2025, they gathered support to formally appeal to the Vatican in an effort to preserve the church. Despite their efforts, the Vatican upheld Bishop Bonnar’s decision, citing adherence to the Code of Canon Law.

The closure of Mother of Sorrows Church is part of a broader trend of historic Catholic churches in the region facing permanent closure. Similar decisions have been made in Ashtabula and Portage counties, reflecting ongoing challenges within the diocese. These closures underscore the complex interplay between pastoral needs, demographic shifts, and institutional sustainability.

The Vatican’s endorsement of the decision highlights the role of canon law in guiding ecclesiastical matters. Bishop Bonnar’s actions were deemed consistent with legal and pastoral guidelines, emphasizing the importance of addressing practical and spiritual needs within the Church. The case illustrates the delicate balance between preserving heritage and adapting to contemporary circumstances.

The closure of Mother of Sorrows Church serves as a reminder of the challenges faced by many religious institutions in maintaining relevance and functionality in a changing world. While the decision may be seen as a loss for some, it reflects the broader context of resource management and the evolving landscape of Catholic ministry.

Source: Read the original report