
Pastor in Birmingham, United Kingdom, Charged With Gross Negligence Manslaughter After Man Drowns During Baptism
Cheryl Reid Bartley, 48, founder of Life Changing Ministries, has been charged with one count of gross negligence manslaughter, according to the Crown Prosecution Service. The charge relates to her role as pastor during a baptism ceremony in which a man died. The reports describe the ceremony as taking place at a private home on Slade Road in Erdington, Birmingham, though one report gives only “Slade Road” and another refers to Birmingham generally.
The man who died was Robert Smith, 61, a grandfather of seven. Reports differ on his background. One says he was from Brixton, London, and another says he was originally from Jamaica and had worked as a barber in London. Reports agree that he drowned on 8 October 2023 in a small pool in the garden of the property during the ceremony, which was carried out by Life Changing Ministries.
The baptism was live-streamed on the ministry’s Facebook page. According to one report, the stream was abruptly cut during the ceremony, and the video was later removed. Another report says the stream unexpectedly cut out, leaving no immediate visual record of the incident. The Associated Press, as cited by one report, said the baptism was livestreamed on social media and organized by Bartley’s ministry. The reports do not agree on every detail of the stream, and the supplied material does not explain why the video was removed. The unexplained gap in the record leaves the public without a complete account of what happened, a matter that calls for a full and truthful accounting (Proverbs 18:17).
Paramedics found Smith dead on arrival, according to one report. West Midlands Police confirmed that the cause of death was drowning.
Bartley has been charged but has not been convicted of any offence. The charge is an allegation that will be tested in court. The Crown Prosecution Service has said she is accused of one count of gross negligence manslaughter, and the supplied reports do not describe any plea, trial, or civil claim.
Bartley, of Erdington, is due to appear at Birmingham Magistrates’ Court on 14 May.
Sources (4):
- Preacher charged with manslaughter after man, 61, drowns during his baptism (metro.co.uk)
- Pastor charged after grandfather of 7 drowns during baptism — and said she saw him ‘dancing with Jesus’ (nypost.com)
- Pastor charged in kiddie pool drowning death during backyard baptism ceremony (katv.com)
- Birmingham pastor charged after man drowned during baptism (bbc.com)