
Former moderate Baptist pastor says churches avoid speaking directly on politics
In a column published on the Baptist News website, a writer recalls working for a self-described “moderate” Baptist church in East Tennessee shortly after Donald Trump was elected president in 2016. The writer describes an unspoken norm in that church and, the writer says, in many similar congregations across the Southeast: pastors do not speak directly about politicians, public policy or political discourse. Instead, the writer says, such churches tend to refer only indirectly to issues such as “unrest,” “polarization” or “partisanship.”
The writer says this caution was defended on several grounds. According to the writer, church leaders feared that directness would disturb the peace of the congregation, that it would mix politics with religion, or that it would lead to “a split.”
The writer reports that a earlier essay published on the same site, titled “Ash Wednesday, or How (not) to Be Baptist in Trump’s America,” drew criticism from both conservative and progressive members of the church. One member, the writer says, called the piece “too direct to be helpful” and said it would make it harder to get important things done. The writer says that the goals behind those “important things” remain undefined.
In the column, the writer argues that moderate church leadership and moderate politics share a common priority of “survival at all costs.” The writer contends that plain speech on current events threatens the institutional stability that such churches prize. The writer also questions what pastors and Bible studies offered to people who took part in the January 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, a characterization the writer offers as opinion. Speaking candidly about such matters, the writer says, requires a willingness to risk something for the good of others, a lesson the writer links to speaking truthfully with care (Ephesians 4:15).
The writer says that the writer has since left the pulpit and now writes from outside pastoral employment. The writer argues that retirement or resignation has freed the writer to speak more directly, and that the writer does not regard this as bravery. The writer also notes that a pastor who depends on a congregation’s support faces pressure, citing the novelist Upton Sinclair’s observation that it is hard to get someone to understand something when their salary depends on not understanding it.
In the final section, the writer argues that the problem is systemic rather than personal. When pastors and politicians are restrained from teaching and defending what they believe is right in order to protect their livelihoods, the writer says, the system that produces such pressure deserves the blame. The writer concludes that replacing individual pastors or politicians would not resolve the problem, which the writer says is sustained by a broader institutional dynamic.
Source: Read the original report