Actor Jay Sefton Stages Play in Easthampton, Massachusetts, About Clergy Abuse Survivor Who Rejects Church Settlement

By Claudette Posted Nov 21, 2026 at 2:12 AM
Share:FacebookXEmail

A play that opens Thursday at CitySpace in Easthampton, Massachusetts, tells the story of a man who was abused by a priest when he was a boy. “Unreconciled” is based on the experience of western Massachusetts actor and playwright Jay Sefton, who co-wrote it with another survivor, Mark Basquill. James Barry directs the production, which runs from Nov. 30 through Dec. 2, 2023, in the Blue Room at Old Town Hall. Sefton plays all of the roles, including the perpetrator.

The main character, who shares Sefton’s name and is also called Jay, is 13 years old when the abuse takes place in 1985 at the Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin Mary school in Philadelphia. In the play, the character turns down money from the Catholic Church. Sefton and others said the priest allegedly abused boys who played the part of Jesus in school plays. The script depicts a school Passion Play in which Jay volunteers for the role, and it describes the priest having Jay undress in a locked closet while other students changed into their costumes.

Sefton said the play is based on facts. He pointed to a grand jury report published in 2005 by the Philadelphia district attorney’s office, which said the Archdiocesan Review Board in 2004 unanimously found that the priest had abused boys who played the part of Jesus over the years. The report’s findings are cited in the production’s background, and the play does not present them as new allegations.

The writers use humor alongside the serious subject matter. Sefton said the lighter moments help audiences avoid worrying about him, and one character, Philly Jay, offers a sharp, comic counterpoint to the lead. Sefton, who is 52, describes the work as a way of addressing the abuse in a form that is difficult but not unbearable for the audience. Protecting children from harm in such settings is the concern the story raises (Proverbs 31:8-9).

Sefton, who works as a mental health counselor, wrote the script with Basquill, a 62-year-old clinical psychologist. Basquill was also abused by a priest in the Archdiocese of Philadelphia.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Easthampton, Hampshire County, Massachusetts, United States

Open map

Claudette

Claudette is GracePress's virtual editorial byline for articles produced by Claude Haiku 5.5, a language model made by Anthropic and reached through Anthropic's API. She does not independently report, interview sources, or witness events. Working from linked source material, the GracePress News Ingest system uses Claude to rewrite articles within campaign-specific rules for factual attribution, careful treatment of allegations, Christian moral context, location extraction, and source disclosure. Every Claudette article identifies its underlying source and is published through GracePress's automated editorial workflow.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer