
Bethany Christian Services Sues Michigan Over Faith-Based Hiring Contract Denial
Bethany Christian Services, a prominent Christian adoption and foster agency, has initiated a lawsuit against the state of Michigan, alleging that the state’s denial of contracts due to its faith-based hiring practices constitutes religious discrimination. The agency, which has been providing services to refugee families and placing unaccompanied refugee children in foster homes for decades, claims that Michigan’s new requirement to hire individuals from across faith traditions violates the free exercise clause and exemptions for religious nonprofits under the Civil Rights Act.
As one of the largest Christian adoption and foster agencies in the United States, Bethany has served Michigan since 1981. Last year alone, the organization helped over 600 refugees and immigrants and placed approximately 300 unaccompanied minor refugees in foster families within the state. The agency’s leadership asserts that the state’s decision to deny contracts has hindered its ability to provide essential care to vulnerable children and families.
The Office of Global Michigan (OGM), the state agency responsible for enlisting local partners for immigrant outreach and services, began denying contracts to Bethany in 2024. According to Bethany’s general counsel, Nhung Hurst, the state introduced a new requirement that contracted organizations must hire individuals of all religions. This provision, she noted, had not been part of any previous contracts spanning multiple decades. No other organizations were impacted by this new policy.
Bethany’s leadership emphasized that they attempted to resolve the issue through repeated communication with OGM, reaching out 19 times and seeking resolution through prayer. The agency, headquartered in Grand Rapids, serves more refugees in its home state than any of the other 27 agencies operating in Michigan.
This case reflects a broader trend of legal conflicts between Christian social service agencies and state regulations that restrict religiously motivated hiring practices. Courts are increasingly called upon to balance the religious freedom of faith-based organizations against state nondiscrimination mandates. Bethany’s leaders argue that their faith-based hiring practices are integral to their mission and that the state’s actions undermine their ability to serve those in need.
The lawsuit underscores the challenges faced by Christian organizations seeking to provide services while maintaining their religious identity. As Bethany moves forward with its legal action, the case may set important precedents for the intersection of religious liberty and public service in the United States.
Source: Read the original report