
Book by Utah Scholar Elise Boxer Argues Anti-Indigenous Racism Runs Through LDS Church
A new book argues that anti-Indigenous racism is woven into the DNA of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. In “Mormon Settler Colonialism: Inventing the Lamanite,” author Elise Boxer, an associate professor at the University of South Dakota, points to Pioneer Day as one example. The holiday marks the day Brigham Young and his band of believers entered the Salt Lake Valley, and it is celebrated with parades featuring handcarts and people in period dress.
Boxer also cites Salt Lake City’s This Is the Place Heritage Park, a mock 19th-century village centered on the arrival and stories of Mormon pioneers. She makes a similar case about the Latter-day Saint children’s song “Book of Mormon Stories,” whose melody is meant to mimic drums and whose lyrics tie Native Americans’ claims to their homelands to their “righteousness.” She further cites the church’s now-ended Indian Student Placement Program, which encouraged families to host Indigenous children and teens during the school year.
The book, which recently won the Mormon History Association’s 2026 award for best Indigenous studies, locates the framework for this treatment in the faith’s founding scripture. Boxer contends that the Book of Mormon, and specifically a group within it called the Lamanites, has shaped the church’s view of Indigenous peoples. The text asserts that the Lamanites are “among the ancestors of the American Indians,” a phrase that replaced the earlier “principal ancestors.” According to the source, the text also describes the group as cursed with dark skin by God for their wickedness, and it leaves them awaiting redemption at the end of the sacred text.
Boxer writes that “Indigenous peoples have been uniquely othered within the LDS Church.” She concludes that these teachings, along with cultural practices past and present, point to an uncomfortable reality. “American Indians will never fully become Mormon,” she writes, and “Indigenous peoples will always be relegated to the Lamanite” identity.
Montana State University associate professor Amanda Hendrix-Komoto said the book comes amid growing interest in the overlap between Mormon and Native American history. She said the author’s background sets it apart. Boxer is Dakota, from the Sisseton and Wahpeton bands, and she was raised in the church. Hendrix-Komoto said Boxer emphasizes that Indigenous nations should be able to define their own histories and cultures, and that she is more willing than others to call out racism within the church and to describe certain things as colonialism. Boxer acknowledges in the book that not all Indigenous current and former Latter-day Saints share her critiques. Still, she argues that, regardless of how individuals feel, the church as a system is rooted in the marginalization of Native people. Hearing the differing views of Indigenous members fairly, as Proverbs 18:17 counsels, is part of weighing the book’s claims (Proverbs 18:17).
Boxer also examines the church’s founder. She describes Joseph Smith as a “quintessential American settler,” and she writes that his teachings that God had called him to build Zion “drove Mormon settler desires tied to the land.”
Source: Read the original report