
Catholic Church’s Opposition to Birth Control Has Changed Over Centuries, Scholar Says
The 50th anniversary of “Humanae Vitae,” Pope Paul VI’s 1968 encyclical, has prompted renewed attention to the Catholic Church’s teaching on contraception. The document strictly prohibited artificial contraception and was issued after the birth control pill was developed. At the time, it shocked many Catholic priests and laypeople, while conservative Catholics praised it as a confirmation of traditional teaching.
According to the article, the Church’s position on contraception has changed and developed over almost 2,000 years, and it has not always been the central battleground it is today. The article notes that ancient Egyptian, Hebrew, Greek and Roman texts describe well-known contraceptive practices, and that nothing in Scripture explicitly prohibits contraception. It says early Christian theologians condemned the practice partly in response to cultural practices and social pressures, and partly as a reaction to heretical groups such as the Gnostics and Manichees. Before the 20th century, theologians reportedly assumed that those who practiced contraception were “fornicators” and “prostitutes,” and that the purpose of marriage was producing offspring.
The article describes the fourth-century theologian Augustine as characterizing marital sex aimed at preventing conception as immoral self-indulgence. It states that for many centuries the Church said little about contraception, and that most medieval penitence manuals did not mention it. The article identifies 1588 as the point when Pope Sixtus V took the strongest conservative stance in Catholic history, through the papal bull “Effraenatam,” which ordered church and civil penalties for homicide to be applied to those who practiced contraception. According to the article, both church and civil authorities refused to enforce these orders, and laypeople largely ignored them. Three years after Sixtus’s death, his successor repealed most of the sanctions and told Christians to treat the bull “as if it had never been issued.”
The article reports that by the mid-17th century some church leaders acknowledged that couples might have legitimate reasons to limit family size. It says that in the 19th century, advances in reproductive science and improved contraceptive technologies led to new discussions, although Victorian-era sensibilities discouraged most Catholic clergy from preaching on sex and contraception. An 1886 penitential manual directed confessors to ask parishioners explicitly about contraception and to refuse absolution unless they stopped, but the article says that order was virtually ignored.
By the 20th century, the article states, Christians in heavily Catholic countries such as France and Brazil were among the most prodigious users of artificial contraception, contributing to a dramatic decline in family size. The article says this increased availability and use led the papacy to make church teaching on birth control a visible priority and to move the discussion from scholarly theological debate into ordinary exchanges between Catholic couples and their priests.
The article concludes with Pope Pius XI’s 1930 encyclical “Casti Connubii,” in which he declared contraception inherently evil. He stated that any spouse practicing contraception “violates the law of God and nature” and is “stained by a great and mortal flaw.”
Source: Read the original report