Chinese 14-year-old pleads not guilty to murder of fellow exchange student in Edgeworth, New South Wales, Australia

A 14-year-old girl, a foreign exchange student from China, has pleaded not guilty to murdering a fellow Chinese exchange student at their host family’s home in Edgeworth, Lake Macquarie, New South Wales. She will face trial in the NSW Supreme Court.

Emergency services were called to the Edgeworth address just before 10.30pm on August 4 last year. Police said the two girls, both exchange students from China, and the couple hosting them had retired to separate bedrooms for the night when the woman heard a commotion. She entered the older girl’s bedroom and found her with a stab wound to her torso, police said. NSW Ambulance paramedics treated the 14-year-old victim, who was taken to hospital in a critical condition, where she later died.

Police arrested the girl, then 13, at the scene and took her to Toronto police station. Lake Macquarie detectives charged her with murder. With assistance from the Homicide Squad, they launched Strike Force Aggnes to investigate the circumstances of the stabbing. Police said they were not aware of any relationship between the two girls beyond their participation in the same exchange program and their stay with the same host family.

On Monday, the accused girl appeared in Broadmeadow Children’s Court for the first time, charged with the stabbing murder. The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions said it was awaiting outstanding evidence from Chinese authorities. The girl’s lawyers said there was no guarantee that material would be made available, and they described the delay as “significant” while their client remained in custody. They have strongly opposed prosecution applications for lengthy adjournments and have repeatedly asked for the earliest possible date.

The girl is said to have a history of mental health issues. A judge last year remarked that she was on an “extraordinary number of medications” and was “severely unwell.” Her mental health could provide a possible defence. The case could also involve doli incapax, a legal principle in NSW that presumes children aged between 10 and 14 are incapable of forming criminal intent. Her lawyers have said the prosecution of a child who is also a foreign national for murder is believed to be unprecedented in Australian legal circles, which makes the case complex. Her vulnerability in the proceedings is a matter the court will need to weigh, a point reflected in the call to speak up for those who cannot speak for themselves (Proverbs 31:8-9).

The girl is expected to be arraigned in the NSW Supreme Court in October, when she is expected to plead not guilty and receive a trial date.

Source: Read the original report