
Cook County Jail wrongful death lawsuit over 2024 beating death set to settle for record $7.25 million
The family of Cory Ulmer, a 41-year-old man with mental illness who died at the Cook County Jail in June 2024, has agreed to dismiss a wrongful death lawsuit against the county in exchange for $7.25 million. The Cook County Board of Commissioners Finance Committee was set to vote Wednesday on the deal, which would need approval from the full board. An Injustice Watch analysis of settlement data found it would be the county’s largest single payout for a jail-related lawsuit since at least 2007.
Cook County Sheriff Tom Dart’s office, which runs the jail, told Ulmer’s family only that he died following a medical emergency. An internal report leaked to Injustice Watch days after his death showed officers repeatedly struck him in the jail’s emergency room after he became “combative.” Later records show the sheriff’s internal investigators found several officers committed misconduct against Ulmer, and two now face termination. One of those officers had been recommended for firing a decade earlier but was allowed to remain on the job, records show.
Records state that Ulmer had been held for at least 24 hours in a small, bedless basement holding cell known as a “bullpen,” awaiting transfer to a psychiatric unit. He tried to run out of the cell, and officers began striking him before dragging him into the emergency room. Witnesses told investigators the officers kicked, punched, and kneed him as he lay facedown, shackled and facing away from security cameras. Records show he was then injected with sedatives, became unresponsive, and was declared dead soon after arriving at Mount Sinai Hospital. The Cook County medical examiner ruled his death a homicide.
Ulmer was taken to the jail a day before his death for violating a court-ordered curfew tied to 2023 assault and armed robbery charges. Officers with the sheriff’s electronic monitoring unit noted he was unwell, walking on the road shirtless after midnight, and one speculated he was “off his meds.” Records show the officers considered taking Ulmer home or to a hospital but took him to the jail instead. The case raises questions about protecting people who cannot defend themselves (Psalm 82:3).
Ulmer’s stepfather, Robert Robinson, sued the county in federal court last year. The suit alleged that officers used excessive force in violation of Ulmer’s constitutional rights and that jail medical staff failed to provide adequate care or antipsychotic medications, “despite obvious signs that his mental state was deteriorating.” In court filings, the county denied those allegations. Dart declined to be interviewed, citing pending litigation, as did Dr. Priscilla Ware, medical director of the jail’s healthcare provider, Cermak Health Services. Ware was not a defendant in the lawsuit.
The sheriff’s Office of Professional Review closed its internal investigation in December 2025, about a year and a half after Ulmer died. Investigators examined the actions of 18 correctional officers and said two should be fired and six should be suspended. Of the 11 medical staffers named in the lawsuit, one has since left the jail. Investigators recommended that Sgt. Enrique Reyes and correctional officer Jason Jackson be terminated. Investigators found both used unnecessary force, and a medical staff member who witnessed the beating told investigators Jackson hit Ulmer the most. Investigators also found that Reyes turned off his body-worn camera during the incident, and they determined his explanation that Ulmer was about to receive medical attention was untrue. Reyes’ firing is before an arbitrator, and Jackson’s fate lies with the sheriff’s Merit Board. According to Dart’s spokesperson, both have been stripped of their police powers and assigned to work at a warehouse.
Jackson had been recommended for firing in 2016, a year after he was hired, over allowing detainees into a visiting area without permission and failing to stop them from masturbating in view of visitors. An arbitrator instead ruled that he should be reinstated six months later. The sheriff’s spokesperson said his roughly 140 workdays of unpaid suspension were considered appropriate discipline. Records also show the county code requires law enforcement to “immediately” notify the medical examiner of a death in custody. The medical examiner was instead notified by a Mount Sinai nurse nearly six hours after Ulmer was pronounced dead, by which time the emergency room had been cleaned. Dart’s spokesperson did not deny the failure to notify but said the office “worked to support every independent investigation conducted by outside agencies in this case.”
Only the Illinois Department of Corrections currently provides external monitoring of the jail, through annual inspections and yearly reports. In September, Cook County Commissioner Tara Stamps and four co-sponsors introduced a resolution calling for an “independent review” of the jail, but she pulled it from a committee vote after colleagues said it could be a legal liability. The county’s civil actions bureau chief warned that the resolution could harm the county’s legal position. In an op-ed published last week, a group of interfaith clergy urged commissioners to advance it. Jennifer Vollen-Katz, executive director of the John Howard Association of Illinois, which monitored the jail from 1988 to 2011, said more oversight could help identify the practices behind these deaths. “Sometimes just knowing you’re being watched prevents people from behaving badly,” she said.
Source: Read the original report