
Coptic Church suspends theological dialogue with Rome over Fiducia supplicans
The Coptic Orthodox Church has decided to suspend its theological dialogue with the Catholic Church, according to a statement from its Holy Synod. The synod said it reached the decision “after consulting with the sister churches of the Eastern Orthodox family.” It also said it would re-evaluate the results the dialogue has achieved since it began twenty years ago and establish new norms and mechanisms before any further dialogue continues. The source reports the decision was announced last Thursday and links it to the Vatican’s declaration *Fiducia supplicans* on blessings for irregular couples, including homosexual couples.
The source notes that the Coptic move came a week after Metropolitan Hilarion, president of the Biblical-Theological Commission of the Moscow Patriarchate, called the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith document a “very serious deviation from Christian moral norms.” The source also says the document had already drawn strong rejection from several African Catholic episcopates.
The decision came out of a plenary session of the Coptic Holy Synod, headed by Pope Tawadros II, held on March 7 at the Logos Center of the Papal Residence in the Monastery of St. Anba Bishoy in Wadi Natroun, Egypt. The source states that 110 of the synod’s 133 members attended.
Alongside the dialogue decision, the synod stated what the source describes as its “firm position of rejecting all forms of homosexual relations,” which it said “violate the Holy Bible and the law by which God created man and woman.” The synod considers “any blessing, whatever its type, for such relations to be a blessing to sin, and this is unacceptable.” A Coptic Church statement issued after the synodal debate said that “God has given mankind free will to live according to His divine will and His divine design for marriage between a man and a woman.”
The statement addressed people with same-sex attraction in several parts. It said a person who “suffers attraction to the same sex, but controls this desire is praised for his efforts and is subject to the same temptations as heterosexual individuals.” It went on to say that if someone “chooses to embrace his homosexual tendency and refuses to seek spiritual and emotional help, but continues to break God’s commandments,” his situation “becomes the same as that of someone living in adultery,” and such people “should be warned and advised to refrain from communion, seeking repentance.”
The statement also said the church “firmly opposes all forms of sexual activity outside the limits of marriage” and “strongly rejects the idea that different cultural contexts can be used to justify same-sex relations under the pretext of human freedom.” It affirmed belief in human rights and freedoms while stating that “these freedoms are not absolute and should not be used to violate the laws of the Creator.” Finally, it expressed a commitment to “helping people with homosexual tendencies,” stating “that it does not reject them, but rather provides support and assistance to help them achieve an emotional and spiritual solution” (Matthew 25:35).
Source: Read the original report (translated from Spanish)