
Federal Lawsuit in Memphis, Tennessee, Accuses Southern Baptist Executive Committee of Covering Up Sexual Abuse
A federal lawsuit names Pastor Steve Gaines of Bellevue Baptist Church and is filed against the Executive Committee of the Southern Baptist Convention, the denomination’s governing body between annual meetings. The lawsuit alleges that the Executive Committee covered up instances of sexual abuse by church members and employees as a strategy of denying survivors’ rights. The Southern Baptist Convention is America’s largest Protestant denomination.
The lawsuit states that it is based in part on a 2019 investigation by the Houston Chronicle and the San Antonio Express News, which it says uncovered widespread sexual abuse in the Southern Baptist Convention. Quoting that investigation, the lawsuit says at least 35 church pastors, employees and volunteers who exhibited predatory behavior still found jobs at churches during the past two decades. It also says the investigation included 200 criminal cases and 700 victims over a 20-year period.
The lawsuit’s account of Bellevue Baptist Church goes back to 2006. According to court records cited in the lawsuit, Bellevue Pastor Steve Gaines and the Southern Baptist Convention failed to immediately fire a sex offender from the church that year. The lawsuit also says Gaines admitted waiting six months to fire a pastor who had confessed to molestation at Bellevue. A report mentioned in the lawsuit found that Bellevue was ill prepared for sexual abuse.
Separately, the Executive Committee contracted an outside review after delegates to the previous year’s national meeting pressed for an independent probe. NPR reported on May 22, 2022, that the resulting 288-page investigation, conducted over seven months by Guidepost Solutions, an independent firm, was issued on a Sunday. The report found that SBC leaders stonewalled and denigrated survivors of clergy sex abuse over almost two decades while seeking to protect their own reputations. It said survivors and other concerned Southern Baptists repeatedly shared allegations with the Executive Committee and met resistance, stonewalling and hostility. Guidepost’s findings are the investigation’s conclusions, and the lawsuit’s claims are allegations that the court has not yet decided.
The report said a few senior Executive Committee leaders, along with outside counsel, largely controlled the committee’s response to abuse reports. In the report’s account, these leaders were singularly focused on avoiding liability for the Southern Baptist Convention, and survivors were ignored, disbelieved or told that the convention could take no action because of its polity. Truthful hearing of a grievance before judgment is a basic duty, a lesson the survivors’ accounts raise directly (Proverbs 18:17).
Sources (2):