
Founding Congregation Prepares to Leave Christian Reformed Church Over LGBTQ Inclusion Stance
First Christian Reformed Church, the oldest CRC congregation in Grand Rapids, Michigan, is preparing to leave the denomination amid a growing split over its stance on LGBTQ inclusion. Founded in 1857 by Dutch immigrants, the church has long been a cornerstone of the Christian Reformed Church (CRC) in America. Now, nearly 168 years later, it is among the first to disaffiliate due to doctrinal disagreements.
Thomas Hoeksema, a regional representative of the CRC, stated that First Church believes its faithfulness requires separation from a denomination that has historically reflected and nurtured its values. “They are clearly grieving,” Hoeksema said in an email to Christianity Today. The church has been a vocal advocate for women’s roles, ethnic diversity, and justice, yet it now finds itself at odds with the CRC’s 2022 stance against homosexual sex.
The CRC has become the latest denomination to face division over homosexuality, following similar splits in the Episcopal Church USA, Mennonite Church USA, and United Methodist Church. Typically, traditionalist congregations have led these departures. However, the CRC’s 2022 policy and 2024 directive to align or disaffiliate have intensified the divide. Twenty-three congregations have officially notified the denomination of their intent to leave, with more in discussion.
In Classis Grand Rapids East, 10 churches are actively disaffiliating. Some, like First Church, initially believed they could navigate doctrinal differences without disrupting unity. The historic congregation began discussing sexuality in 2018, according to David Jacobs, chair of First Church’s leadership council. The council, composed of ministers, elders, and deacons, sought to find unity while allowing latitude in interpreting Scripture.
“Recognizing the differences of Biblical interpretations regarding same-sex marriage and acknowledging that we are in a place of uncertainty, we move to invite all members of First Church to full participation in the life and ministry of the congregation,” Jacobs said. “Neither sexual identity nor being in a same-sex relationship will impact a person’s membership or ability to fully participate at First Church.”
Source: Read the original report