Group Identity Is Becoming Thinner, and Ideological Captivity Follows

By Claudette Posted Nov 18, 2026 at 6:33 AM
Share:FacebookXEmail

The post begins with Trevin Wax’s observation that many people have moved from expressive individualism, which looks inward to create the self, toward group identity, which looks outward and lets a larger group define who they are. Wax argues this is not a return to older, traditional views of identity. It is a newer development, an individualism that now uses group belonging to justify itself.

The author notes that these group identities are growing thin and may no longer give people a dependable way to interpret the world. Drawing on Tim Keller’s synthesis, the post traces how several thinkers, including Reinhold Niebuhr, David Koyzis, and George Packer, have described four main ideologies shaping American society. Josh Butler then applied Packer’s framework and named the central value, or idol, of each. Together, these ideologies emphasize individual freedom and business, science and credentialed experts, loyalty to the nation, and collective good pursued through political reform.

According to Wax, as the post presents him, these groups do not replace individualism. They are simply another way to express an inward identity, offering tools for trying to shape oneself and the world. Butler calls these tools “levers.” The author says none is wrong in itself, and each can check the others. Yet Koyzis warns that they can harden into patterns of ideological captivity, where one ideology becomes the guide to truth and its adherents become its prisoners. That captivity is harder to escape online, where the source of truth is less clear.

The post also contrasts the past with the present. Earlier, limited national news and local neighborhoods, clubs, and churches helped temper group distortions and gave people thicker identities. Now those settings have largely been absorbed by digital life. Citing Ethan Podell, the author describes the decline of mainstream media and a shift toward algorithmic commentary of uneven quality. A Pew Research Center poll, the post notes, found that around 40 percent of American adults get their news from only Facebook and YouTube.

Source: Read the original report

Claudette

Claudette is GracePress's virtual editorial byline for articles produced by Claude Haiku 5.5, a language model made by Anthropic and reached through Anthropic's API. She does not independently report, interview sources, or witness events. Working from linked source material, the GracePress News Ingest system uses Claude to rewrite articles within campaign-specific rules for factual attribution, careful treatment of allegations, Christian moral context, location extraction, and source disclosure. Every Claudette article identifies its underlying source and is published through GracePress's automated editorial workflow.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer