
Haaretz Reports Pakistan Uses Israeli-Linked Surveillance Technology Despite No Diplomatic Ties
A recent report in the Israeli newspaper Haaretz claimed that Pakistan has been using Israeli technology for security purposes, even though the two countries have no diplomatic relations or trade ties. The report stated that “Pakistan’s Federal Investigation Agency and various police units [have been] using an Israeli digital intelligence company’s cyber technology software to tackle crime, espionage, and terrorist financing since 2012.” It said the Israeli company Celebrate supplied its products to Pakistan through its Singapore subsidiary.
The story drew attention in Pakistan. The Foreign Affairs Ministry did not respond officially. Former Foreign Minister Khawaja Muhammad Asif said in a statement that “hacking technology and software are available in the international market” and that “it is not correct to say that we have taken the technology directly from the Israeli firm.” He added that security agencies acquire whatever is available or the best product on the international market.
The source notes that revelations about international use of Israeli-made spyware or digital surveillance technology are not new. It recalls that in July 2021, Reuters reported that Pakistan had called on the United Nations to investigate whether India used Israeli-made Pegasus spyware to spy on public figures in Pakistan, including Prime Minister Imran Khan. Reuters described a list compiled by an investigation involving 17 international media organizations and Amnesty International, which said Khan’s phone number was among potential surveillance targets for countries that had bought the spyware.
Separately, unnamed sources were quoted as saying that the Israel-based companies Elbit Systems and Rafael Advanced Defense Systems “have been providing security assistance to Pakistan, and their products have been used by the Pakistan Armed Forces.” The article describes Elbit Systems as offering electronic warfare, command-control, and training and simulation systems, and Rafael Advanced Defense Systems as offering air defense, missile defense, and anti-tank systems. The source also observes that Israel and Pakistan have no formal diplomatic relations, so any assistance from Israeli companies would likely pass through third-party intermediaries. It suggests some cooperation may exist but is likely less extensive than some claim. Pakistan has said it will not recognize Israel while the Palestinian issue remains unresolved, and the 2020 Abraham Accords have revived questions about relations with other states. The article also says no concrete evidence has been produced to support the claim, and that the reports could be a conspiracy theory. Verifying a serious allegation before repeating it reflects the honest dealing that truth requires (Proverbs 11:1).
Dr. Baqir Malik, an assistant professor at the School of Politics and International Relations at Quaid-i-Azam University in Islamabad, told The Media Line that “it is important to verify the accuracy of the claim that Pakistan is using Israeli spy devices.” He said that if the claim were true, analysts would need to examine the software’s capabilities, potential vulnerabilities and possible uses. Malik also said Pakistani politicians “may take advantage of anti-Israel sentiments for political gain,” and that perceptions of such tools could increase tensions with other regional countries. He argued that Pakistan and Israel both have strategic reasons to build relations, but that Pakistan’s public reaction and political consequences could make this difficult in the near future, so Pakistan “obtains its strategic equipment through a third party.”
Irina Tsukerman, a New York-based national security expert and specialist on South Asia, told The Media Line that “political goals are all about timing.” She said Pakistan was “clearly being targeted due to the recent public discussions of possible limited openness to Track 2 diplomacy with Israel.” In her view, showing that multiple Pakistani institutions had allegedly used Israeli technology “would create an impression of hypocrisy and double standards and could lead to civil unrest and change in power.”
Source: Read the original report