
Idaho voters reject abortion rights measure as Latter-day Saints and Catholics oppose it
Idaho voters rejected Proposition 1, the “Reproductive Freedom and Privacy Act,” by a vote of 55.94% to 44.06% last week. Heavy opposition from Catholics and The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints contributed to the defeat, which came after a heavy flood of campaign advertising.
The initiative would have amended Idaho law to establish a state right to abortion. It was introduced four years after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that there is no federal right to abortion. In other states on the same ballot, Nevada and Virginia voters approved constitutional amendments establishing abortion rights, and Missouri voters defeated a measure that would have repealed the constitutional abortion right they had approved in 2024.
Leaders of the church opposed expanding abortion in Idaho and encouraged members to “voice their opposition” to Prop 1. Their letter, which was read from the pulpit twice during worship services in the faith’s 1,300 Idaho congregations, said, “We join with other like-minded individuals and organizations working against this initiative,” and urged members to voice opposition “in a respectful manner consistent with prophetic direction of always demonstrating Christlike love and civility in political discourse” (Romans 12:18). The church also donated $1 million to Too Extreme for Idaho, the political action committee that funded the interfaith coalition against the initiative. Idaho Catholic philanthropists James and Angela Harris also gave $1 million to the PAC.
Boise State Public Radio reported that the interfaith coalition was organized by Idaho Family Policy Center leader Blaine Conzatti, Catholic Diocese of Boise lobbyist Christian Welp and Latter-day Saint representative Tom Luna. Conzatti said in a statement, as reported by Stateline, that “abortion advocates fundamentally misunderstood Idaho.” He added, “As we proved last night, a broad majority of Idaho voters support our pro-life laws. This is what happens when Christians speak out and get engaged — we win.”
Campaign finance figures show the scale of spending. The two opposing political action committees raised a total of $9,624,948.97 as of Oct. 1, and the next reports are due Tuesday. As of that date, Too Extreme for Idaho had raised $4,675,626.16 and spent $4,266,877.80, with $3,961,758.00 of that spending going to broadcast advertising. The campaign for Prop 1 was funded by Idahoans United for Women and Families Inc., which had raised $4,949,322.81 as of Oct. 1.
The vote is also shaping the next phase of the debate. Supporters of the initiative are urging residents to press lawmakers who advocated rejecting Prop 1 in favor of a legislative fix that would add exceptions. A federal appeals court upheld Idaho’s abortion ban on Oct. 30, but ruled that the state’s law does not provide exceptions for a pregnant woman whose physical or mental health is in jeopardy, according to the Idaho Capital Sun. The Sun reported that Idaho doctors have said the law leaves them feeling compelled to wait until a patient’s life is in danger before acting, and that Idaho women have sought care in other states, including Utah, when facing fatal fetal anomalies or a lack of care for a miscarriage.
“We’re encouraging Idahoans to reach out to their lawmakers, particularly those politicians who encouraged voters to reject Prop 1 and wait for a legislative fix, and demand needed exceptions in the coming session,” said Melanie Folwell, executive director of Idahoans United for Women and Families, in remarks to the Sun.
Source: Read the original report