
Nondenominational Church Challenges New York City Policy on Worship in Public Schools
Abounding Grace Ministries, a nondenominational church based in New York City, recently held what may be one of its final worship services at FDR Public School on Manhattan’s Lower East Side. The church had rented space in the school for the past three years, with Pastor Rick Del Rio emphasizing that the reasonable cost was essential for serving his predominantly low-income congregation.
Del Rio described the school as a vital community hub, where families could gather and build relationships. He expressed concern over New York City’s policy restricting worship services in public schools, which he viewed as unfair to the people his church serves. “At the expense of the poor they want to go ahead and make this decision,” he said, questioning how his congregation would be informed about the policy’s implications.
Barry Lynn, executive director of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, argued that allowing churches to use public school facilities creates a constitutional issue. He explained that regular use of a school by a religious group could lead the community or students to perceive a special connection between that religious group and the school.
Del Rio and other opponents of the policy contend that churches are treated differently than other groups, such as Alcoholic Anonymous and the Boy Scouts, which are still permitted to rent space in New York City public schools. Lynn countered that the law prohibits certain activities in public schools, including commercial events, partisan political rallies, and worship services, asserting that this is not viewpoint discrimination.
Thousands of churches across the country continue to worship in public schools, according to Del Rio. He warned that New York City’s policy could set a precedent in a broader movement toward secularization. “If you think Occupy Wall Street can make some noise, there is going to be some real movement here from communities like ours,” he said, expressing determination to resist the policy.
Abounding Grace has found a temporary worship location and joined a coalition of churches challenging the policy. The church remains committed to providing a space for worship and community engagement, even as it navigates the legal and ethical complexities of its situation.
Source: Read the original report