
Ohio Court Lets Dad’s Place in Bryan, Ohio, Continue Sheltering Homeless as Case Proceeds
A federal court ruled that Dad’s Place, a church in Bryan, Ohio, can continue sheltering people in need while its legal case proceeds, according to a report from Daily Citizen. Pastor Chris Avell began opening the church to people in need in March 2023. Another report, from 13abc.com, describes a judge’s denial of a request to shut the church down. The two reports differ on the court involved, and the source material does not resolve that difference.
According to the Daily Citizen report, the city of Bryan sent a cease and desist letter ordering the church to stop allowing overnight guests within 10 days or face criminal prosecution. After the church refused to comply, the city filed 18 separate criminal charges. That report says a panel of judges from Ohio’s Sixth District Court of Appeals reversed a previous ruling that had closed the ministry. The judges noted that the trial court had not considered Pastor Avell’s religious liberty under the Ohio Constitution’s Conscience Clause.
The same report says that in February 2024, the city agreed to drop the criminal charges if Pastor Avell ceased operations. Two months later, however, the city filed more criminal charges against him. In January 2025, according to the report, Pastor Avell was found guilty of a criminal charge related to a fire code violation.
The 13abc.com report describes a separate legal dispute that began in 2024, when the city sued after the church allowed homeless people to stay overnight. The city alleged violations of zoning and fire codes, including the absence of a sprinkler system. The fire chief asked a judge to shut the church down until those issues were addressed. The judge ruled that the fire chief did not have enough specific interest to order a closure.
The 13abc.com report also cites the judgment document, which says the fire code includes cost-based exemptions for buildings similar to Dad’s Place, categorized as Resident Group R. According to the document, motels, apartments and secular charities are not required to meet the same sprinkler requirement because they are grandfathered. The judge listed several alternatives to forcing the church to close its ministry over the lack of a sprinkler system. The judge said any one of those alternatives was fatal to Chief Pool’s case under strict scrutiny.
Sources (2):
- Ohio Court Rules Church Can Shelter Homeless as Case Moves Forward (dailycitizen.focusonthefamily.com)
- Judge denies request to shut down Bryan church in homeless shelter dispute (13abc.com)