Quaker essay argues for abolishing ICE

By Gwen Posted Nov 6, 2026 at 3:55 AM
Share:FacebookXEmail

In an essay published on the American Friends Service Committee’s news page, a Quaker writer argues that the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency should be abolished. The author ties the argument to the Quaker conviction that every person has inherent dignity and humanity.

The essay begins with the author’s experience in 2012, when they accompanied a young immigrant woman to a deportation hearing in Denver. The woman was the mother of a sixteen-month-old child who was a U.S. citizen. The author writes that her only offense was entering the United States without papers. Her immigration attorney told her she had exhausted her legal options and advised her to accept voluntary departure. She would need to check in with the U.S. Embassy in Mexico City within four months to show she had left the country, or she would face detention and forced deportation. The author describes her partner, who was from Ecuador, and says she seemed to face untenable choices: leave her partner and child in the United States, take her child and leave her partner, or stay and go into hiding.

The author writes that accompanying her felt both important and insufficient. In the author’s view, the situation was cruel, and the broader system needed to be “upended, disrupted, abolished.” The essay says immigrants and their allies have been working toward that goal for years.

The author then turns to more recent events. The essay states that more than 2,000 children have been separated from their families by ICE after arriving at the border as asylum seekers, and it says these children have been deeply traumatized. It also says the Trump administration has escalated its targeting of immigrants and created “concentration camp tent facilities” to house immigrant children. The author places these actions alongside earlier practices, including the Obama administration’s deportations, which the essay puts at 2.6 million people. The essay also cites historical examples it describes as tools of colonialism and white supremacy, including the separation of enslaved families, the Indian boarding school system, and the wartime internment of Japanese families.

Several of the author’s claims are presented as conclusions rather than verified findings. The essay asserts that ICE is “an agency of white nationalism,” that it is “racist,” and that it is “a rogue agency.” It cites figures without identifying a separate source in the text. These include about 226,000 people deported by ICE in 2017, 1,224 complaints of sexual and physical abuse filed by people in immigrant detention between 2010 and 2017, and a cost of $775 per night per child for tents used to house separated children on the border. The essay also says more than 20 immigration activists have been arrested by ICE since Trump took office, and it describes this as an infringement of First Amendment rights. The author further claims the agency has been “charged repeatedly” with racial profiling and biased enforcement, and that it has proposed a policy to check the immigration status of sponsors and adult household members of unaccompanied children.

The essay draws on the Quaker abolitionists Benjamin Lay, John Woolman, and Lucretia Mott, whom the author says called for the immediate end of slavery rather than its reform. The author quotes Mott’s account of an 1833 convention in Philadelphia that took the position of “immediate, not gradual, emancipation.” The author argues that ICE “can’t be reformed” and says the agency should be defunded and abolished. The essay states that Quaker belief holds that “freedom of movement and finding a safe home are human rights,” and it presents protecting children and families from separation as part of that conviction (Proverbs 31:8-9).

The essay closes by returning to the young woman from 2012. The author says they often wonder whether she left the country or remains in hiding, and whether her son, who would now be six and a half, is safe and with his mother. The author writes that abolishing ICE is “a first step” toward ending what the author calls “the nightmare” for immigrant families.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Denver, Colorado, United States

Open map

Gwen

Gwen is an AI-assisted editorial byline. Articles attributed to Gwen are drafted with a Qwen language model running locally on Jason's desktop computer and are reviewed before publication.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer