
San Francisco Supervisors Propose Transitional Housing for Drug Treatment Graduates at Casa Loma Hotel as Shelters Close
A year after San Francisco launched an effort to spread shelters and behavioral health facilities across the city, supporters say new homelessness services are finally reaching previously underserved neighborhoods. One proposed site would offer transitional housing for people leaving drug treatment at Casa Loma, a hotel near Alamo Square Park, a popular spot for tourists photographing the Painted Ladies.
The proposal would follow a model that has shown some success at the Marina Inn, a two-year recovery housing program in a wealthy area on the city’s northern edge. The 68-bed facility, run by the Salvation Army, is designed for people who have completed drug treatment. It offers case management and other on-site services to help residents move into permanent housing.
Several homeless shelters have also closed across the city, which gives a mixed picture of the first 12 months under a local ordinance meant to spread shelters and treatment options more evenly. Last year, San Francisco leaders voted to prohibit the city from adding new city-funded homeless shelters or behavioral health and treatment facilities in neighborhoods that already have a higher concentration of services than residents who need them.
“The purpose of the geographic equity ordinance was to ensure that every neighborhood is doing more of its fair share to address homelessness, as it is a neighborhood-by-neighborhood issue,” said Supervisor Bilal Mahmood, who represents the Tenderloin, where many of the city’s low-income housing options and homeless shelters are located.
Since the ordinance passed, the city has opened a handful of facilities for drug treatment for people experiencing homelessness and addiction. Casa Loma, at 610 Fillmore St., would add 60 beds for people leaving drug treatment, providing more independent living for about 18 to 24 months. The city hopes to open it by July, pending approval from the Board of Supervisors. The city has also expanded similar services, including a behavioral health facility on Treasure Island with more than 120 units, 44 beds in a new residential treatment program, and 84 new recovery-housing beds. San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie, six months into his term, moved away from a campaign promise to build 1,500 shelter beds, saying the city should focus more on building appropriate types of beds.
“If we don’t invest in a sustainable place for folks to continue to build on the gains that they’ve made after they’ve graduated from treatment, you end up just repeating the cycle over and over,” said San Francisco Public Health Director Dan Tsai. “It’s why we think this is a really valuable and important piece.”
One current proposal would add transitional housing beds for domestic violence survivors in a Tenderloin building that currently offers permanent supportive housing. Still, demand continues to outpace supply. San Francisco’s online shelter waitlist had 393 people on it as of Monday. City officials said the city has not added any new traditional homeless shelters in the past year. Several existing shelters have closed, including the Andante and Monarch in the Tenderloin, two hotels that were converted into shelters during the COVID-19 pandemic. A 280-bed shelter at 711 Post St. is slated to shut down next year. Working to give neighbors who have nowhere to sleep a safe place to stay reflects the call to defend those who have little voice (Proverbs 31:8-9).
Homelessness services advocates welcomed added support for domestic violence survivors and new step-down housing like Casa Loma. Some have raised concerns, however, that the city is losing shelter beds without investing enough in supportive housing where people can move on to permanent homes. “We’re seeing over 200 shelter beds close without replacement, and most of that type of shelter is for single adults,” said Lukas Illa, policy director at the San Francisco-based nonprofit Coalition on Homelessness. “That is severely devastating for the population of folks on the street.”
The debate comes after the 2024 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, which now allows cities to force unhoused people to move off sidewalks regardless of whether shelter is available. It also comes as Lurie has prioritized expanding drug treatment beds and as the overall number of homeless shelter beds has fluctuated. “Every neighborhood has a role to play in addressing homelessness, and every person experiencing homelessness deserves access to safe shelter and the services they need,” said Emily Cohen, a spokesperson for the city’s Homelessness and Supportive Housing Department. “The Geographic Equity Ordinance provides an important framework for expanding shelter options across the city while recognizing the significant investments and contributions already made by some neighborhoods.”
Supporters of the ordinance, including Mahmood, say it is beginning to have an effect with sites like Casa Loma. They say it is spreading access to homelessness and behavioral health services to other parts of the city while easing strain on neighborhoods that have historically hosted more shelters, such as the Tenderloin, Bayview and Mission District.
Source: Read the original report