Southern Baptist Convention Faces Tension Over Lakepointe Church’s Policies Amid Saddleback’s Exclusion

By Gwen Posted Oct 18, 2026 at 7:17 PM
Share:FacebookXEmail

The Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) will host its 2025 annual meeting in Dallas, a city where megachurch pastors have frequently been in the news for abuse scandals or controversies involving gender roles. This context sets the stage for one of the most glaring hypocrisies expected at the meeting: the SBC’s reluctance to apply the same standards to Josh Howerton and Lakepointe Church as it did to Rick Warren and Saddleback Church in 2023.

Saddleback Church faced significant backlash in 2021 after ordaining three women who were longtime staff members. When Andy Wood was named successor to Rick Warren, his wife, Stacie, was also appointed as a teaching pastor. As a result, the SBC removed Saddleback from the denomination, citing its departure from traditional gender roles in pastoral leadership.

In contrast, Lakepointe Church, led by Josh Howerton, has openly affirmed the role of women in ministry. A former leader at Lakepointe stated, “Josh Howerton does believe in female pastors and Lakepointe does ordain female pastors, allows women to preach during weekend services, and allows women to hold the title of pastor as employees of Lakepointe.” For instance, Tiffany Rutledge, who identifies as the “central marriage groups pastor” for Lakepointe, shares her role on social media. Additionally, Pamela Baltazar preached at Lakepointe’s Mother’s Day service this year.

The former Lakepointe leader noted the inconsistency, saying, “Lakepointe’s position is bizarre because Saddleback was removed from the SBC for the very thing Lakepointe does openly.” Both churches allow women to preach and ordain female pastors, yet Saddleback was excluded while Lakepointe remains a member.

Some argue that Lakepointe maintains male headship in its highest leadership roles. For example, Baltazar referred to preaching “under the fathers of this house — our pastors, our elders.” Similarly, Saddleback’s Rick Warren stated in a 2023 interview that while the church allows women to preach, “the senior pastor is to be a man, a married man of one wife.”

The disparity between Saddleback’s removal and Lakepointe’s continued membership appears to hinge on public perception. Warren’s reputation for kindness contrasted with Howerton’s openly misogynistic remarks. However, with Warren’s retirement, his public image no longer influences the SBC. Lakepointe continues under Howerton’s leadership, while Saddleback is now led by Andy Wood.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Dallas, Dallas County, Texas, United States

Open map

Gwen

Gwen is an AI-assisted editorial byline. Articles attributed to Gwen are drafted with a Qwen language model running locally on Jason's desktop computer and are reviewed before publication.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer