
Supreme Court Rules 7-2 That Columbia, Missouri, Lutheran Church Could Not Be Barred From Playground Grant
In 2012, Missouri created a program that gave grants to qualifying organizations to use recycled tires to resurface playgrounds. That year the state selected 14 recipients for its Scrap Tire Program, which is administered by the Missouri Department of Natural Resources. Trinity Lutheran Church’s Learning Center, which had been established in 1980 as a not-for-profit and merged with Trinity Lutheran Church in 1985, applied. Its playground surface was pea gravel, and the church wanted to replace it with a pour-in-place rubber surface.
Missouri denied the grant because the Learning Center was operated by a church. According to an Alliance Defending Freedom account, the state itself had ranked the church fifth out of 44 applicants. The church then filed a federal lawsuit, which eventually reached the U.S. Supreme Court. That advocacy group’s report described the denial as religious discrimination by the state, a characterization the state did not adopt in the reports summarized here.
Gov. Eric Greitens reversed a Missouri policy in April 2017 that had banned religious organizations from receiving certain state grants. Later that year, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 7-2 in favor of Trinity Lutheran Church in Columbia, Missouri, which had sought state funding to put a soft surface on its preschool playground. Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that it is “odious to our Constitution” to exclude the church from the grant program. Concern for the young children who use the preschool playground reflects a call to speak up for those who cannot speak for themselves (Proverbs 31:8-9).
The church was represented by Alliance Defending Freedom, based in Arizona. Senior counsel Erik Stanley said the decision means “the government has to treat religious people the same as any other community member.” Missouri Attorney General Josh Hawley called the ruling a “great day” for the church and an “even better day for religious freedom in America.”
Daniel Mach of the American Civil Liberties Union took a different view. He said “religious freedom should protect unwilling taxpayers from funding church property, not force them to foot the bill.” The reports summarized here present these positions as the views of the parties and their representatives, not as findings of the court.
The National Constitution Center reported that the Supreme Court said on Monday that a divided court found the Missouri church had a right to receive a public grant for rubber playground materials. The court stopped short of determining whether Missouri’s Blaine Amendment was unconstitutional.
Sources (3):
- Trinity Lutheran Wins! Supreme Court Rules Missouri Engaged in Religious Discrimination (adflegal.org)
- Supreme Court rules for church in playground materials case – The National Constitution Center (constitutioncenter.org)
- US Supreme Court rules for Columbia, Mo., church in playground case (stlpr.org)