Town of Oyster Bay Withdraws from Settlement Agreement with Bethpage Mosque

By Gwen Posted Oct 12, 2026 at 10:44 AM
Share:FacebookXEmail

The Town of Oyster Bay has withdrawn from a previously agreed settlement with the Muslims on Long Island, which would have approved the expansion of the Masjid Al-Baqi mosque in Bethpage and included a payment of $3.95 million to the group. The decision came after further legal review, as stated by Oyster Bay Town Attorney Frank Scalera, who emphasized the town’s commitment to defending its zoning authority.

Muhammad Faridi, representing the Muslims on Long Island, criticized the town’s reversal, noting that the settlement had been filed in federal court. He accused the town of yielding to “bigoted voices” and failing to uphold its legal obligations. “The law does not permit elected officials to cave to prejudice,” he stated, adding that the court would not tolerate such actions.

The dispute began when the Muslims on Long Island filed a lawsuit against the Town of Oyster Bay in January, challenging the rejection of their mosque expansion application. The group cited multiple legal provisions, including the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, the First and 14th Amendments, and New York state law. They argued that the town’s actions violated their constitutional rights.

The mosque sought to replace two one-story buildings with a single, larger structure. The town had blocked the expansion, citing a 2022 change in local law that increased the required number of parking spaces for places of worship. The initial proposal called for 88 parking spaces, but the revised requirement raised the number to 155.

A settlement agreement was reached on August 19, with the town given 10 days to approve it. However, the town ultimately decided to withdraw, citing concerns over traffic safety and parking. Scalera stated that the case centers on these issues rather than religion, emphasizing the town’s duty to protect public safety.

The town’s decision has been met with disappointment by local residents involved in the case. Imran Makda, a Bethpage congregant, expressed frustration, stating that the town’s reversal was a betrayal of its earlier commitment. “We believed the town when it signed the settlement,” he said, adding that the decision reflects a failure to honor their word.

Moeen Qureshi, another plaintiff, echoed Makda’s sentiment, noting that the town’s refusal to uphold its promise strengthens the group’s resolve to proceed with the case in court. The situation highlights broader tensions between religious institutions and local governance, underscoring the importance of legal accountability and the rule of law.

Source: Read the original report

Kingdom News Location

Bethpage, Town of Oyster Bay, Nassau County, New York, 11714, United States

Open map

Gwen

Gwen is an AI-assisted editorial byline. Articles attributed to Gwen are drafted with a Qwen language model running locally on Jason's desktop computer and are reviewed before publication.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer