United Methodist Bishops Issue Statement Clarifying Judicial Council Ruling on Same-Sex Weddings

United Methodist bishops have issued a statement clarifying the implications of a recent Judicial Council decision regarding same-sex weddings. The ruling, released on April 29, reaffirms that pastors have the discretion to decide whether to officiate at any marriage ceremony. It specifically states that a church’s trustees cannot compel or prohibit their pastor from performing same-sex weddings within the church facility.

The decision came to light during the bishops’ April 27-May 2 meeting in Chicago. Concerns about the ruling led to numerous messages from United Methodists and others. On the final day of the meeting, the Council of Bishops approved a statement addressing the decision.

The bishops emphasized that context is crucial in understanding how the ruling applies. “As bishops, we expect that the pastors we appoint will continue to exercise their authority with deep pastoral sensitivity to the congregation and community to which they are appointed,” the statement said. It also affirmed that the Judicial Council decision does not override the powers and duties specific to the central conferences.

Central conferences, which include regions in Africa, Europe, and the Philippines, operate under different legal and cultural contexts. In many of these areas, same-sex weddings conflict with both local interpretations of Scripture and national law. The bishops’ statement clarified that Decision 1516 does not permit United Methodist clergy to violate civil law in their ministry.

Last year, the General Conference, the denomination’s legislative body, passed legislation allowing central conferences to set their own standards for clergy ordination and marriage rites. This measure, now found in Paragraph 544.15 of the Book of Discipline, was approved just before the denomination lifted broad bans on gay clergy and same-sex weddings.

The Philippines, West Africa, and other central conferences have established policies recognizing marriage only between a man and a woman. “It is our understanding that Judicial Council Decision 1516 does not take away the rights of central conferences given in the Book of Discipline to determine policies on rites and ceremonies, including marriage,” said Bishop David Bard, who submitted the statement.

Source: Read the original report