Washington State Settles Suit by Orthodox and Catholic Clergy Over Abuse Reporting Law

By Gwen Posted Oct 15, 2026 at 9:53 AM Updated Nov 2, 2026 at 1:03 PM
Share:FacebookXEmail

Washington state enacted a law in May 2025 that would require clergy to act as mandatory reporters of child sexual abuse, physical abuse, and neglect, even when they learned of the abuse during a confidential sacred rite. According to a report from The Conversation, the law departed from the state’s earlier approach, which had excluded clergy entirely from mandatory reporting duties that applied to other professionals. In the same month, Seattle Archbishop Paul Etienne warned priests that breaking the seal of confession would result in excommunication, according to NCR Online. Under canon law, the report noted, the seal of confession is absolute and inviolable.

Groups of Catholic and Orthodox clergy sued to block the law, arguing that it violated their religious freedom. An Orthodox report from OSV News says Orthodox churches in Washington filed a federal lawsuit, and that the state’s Catholic bishops were also challenging the law. The U.S. Department of Justice intervened in the case. According to The Conversation, the Justice Department claimed the law discriminated against Catholics. NCR Online reported that the bill faced strong opposition from the state’s three Catholic dioceses and from the Justice Department, and that it was supported by advocates for clergy abuse survivors.

In mid-October 2025, the state announced it would not enforce the mandatory reporting requirement for information learned during confidential rites. The Conversation reported that a federal court approved the state’s agreements with the clergy groups. Under those agreements, clergy are included in the list of mandatory reporters but are not required to report information learned during confidential rites. The Conversation also noted that the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox churches hold that clergy are bound by strict confidentiality during confession or sacraments.

The reports describe the October outcome differently. The Conversation says the state “would not enforce” the requirement for information learned in confidential rites. NCR Online says the state “withdrew a mandate” requiring priests to report allegations of sexual abuse disclosed in confession. Catholic supporters of the original statute, as NCR Online reported, had argued that the church has a legal and ethical duty to report sexual abuse revealed during confession. The reports do not describe any finding on the merits of the constitutional claims.

The law’s requirement to report abuse was framed as a way to protect children, a concern that NCR Online linked to the advocates who supported the bill. North Carolina, by contrast, requires any person who suspects abuse to report it, without exception, according to The Conversation.

NCR Online also pointed to wider context on the sacrament itself. Recent studies, it reported, suggest that only a minority of American Catholics seek out confession. Boston College historian James O’Toole examines the rise and fall of confession in America in his book *For I Have Sinned*.

Sources (3):

Kingdom News Location

Washington, United States

Open map

Gwen

Gwen is an AI-assisted editorial byline. Articles attributed to Gwen are drafted with a Qwen language model running locally on Jason's desktop computer and are reviewed before publication.

Join the conversation

Christ, Peer to Peer