
YouVersion Founder Says AI Chatbots Pose Accuracy and Safety Risks on Bible Questions
YouVersion, the nonprofit behind the Bible App, has more than a billion downloads. Its founder and CEO, Bobby Gruenewald, spoke with Christianity Today while in New York to unveil a Times Square ad campaign for Global Bible Month, a November effort to encourage readers to spend more time in Scripture.
The interviewer cited new data showing that half of the Christian questions sent to ChatGPT concern interpreting the Bible, and asked how YouVersion addresses that trend. Gruenewald said people often treat the technology as an oracle that can answer any question and is smarter than they are. He said such tools are, by design, highly fluent, and that people have generally associated fluency with intelligence. Users can lose sight of the fact that an answer could be badly wrong, correct, or somewhere in between. “You don’t know unless you already know the answer,” he said.
Gruenewald said AI differs from ordinary software in a way that matters. Because it is nondeterministic and has variability by design, an incorrect answer is not simply a bug to be fixed. He said the organization is eager to adapt new technology to its mission, but that accuracy guides its decisions, and confidence in accuracy is important.
YouVersion built a prototype of a chatbot that could answer any question about the Bible four or five years ago, Gruenewald said, but has not released it. He gave two or three reasons. One is that answering accurately with confidence is very difficult, and in some cases, he said, it might not be possible with current technology.
He also said the app carries an implied authority that the organization does not intend. People may attribute what comes from the Bible App to God himself, which he called “not proper theology.” The team must therefore think carefully about how users might presume an answer is not only right but carries spiritual authority.
Safety was another concern. Gruenewald said there are likely people every day who are suicidal and download the app while searching for answers. For some, he said, it is an app of last resort in desperate circumstances. Protecting people in such situations is a matter of defending the weak (Psalm 82:3). He said an open-ended chatbot answering “What does the Bible say about ___?” would be an open invitation for some users to discuss the most challenging situations in their lives. By comparison, he said, a chat interface about financial data from Bloomberg would carry a very low probability of that kind of disclosure, because it concerns finance.
Gruenewald said that responsibly, a person with training, education and understanding would be needed to help people navigate some of the complex situations they face.
Source: Read the original report