
Abington Monthly Meeting Takes Steps to Acknowledge 1738 Disownment of Benjamin Lay
Benjamin Lay, an 18th-century Quaker known for his opposition to slavery, entered a Quaker meetinghouse in Burlington, New Jersey, on September 19, 1738, during the Philadelphia Yearly Meeting, according to a Smithsonian Magazine report. Lay wore a great coat that concealed a military uniform and a sword. He carried a hollowed-out book containing a tied-off animal bladder filled with red pokeberry juice. Lay told the gathering that slave keeping was the greatest sin in the world and asked how a people who profess the golden rule could keep slaves.
The Smithsonian account says Lay then plunged a sword through the book, spattering the red liquid, which looked like blood, onto the slaveholders present. Several Quakers surrounded Lay and carried him out of the building, and he did not resist. The report adds that for nearly a quarter-century Lay railed against slavery in Quaker meetings in and around Philadelphia. A Quaker.org.uk article describes the same episode but says the object was a Bible filled with pokeberry juice, which Lay stabbed to symbolize the violence of slavery. The two accounts differ on whether the item was a hollowed-out book or a Bible.
According to the Quaker.org.uk report, Lay was born in England in 1682 and worked as a sailor, where his small stature helped him navigate ship rigging. His experiences in Barbados, where he witnessed chattel slavery, shaped his convictions. La Vie des Idées, which places his birth in 1682 in Essex, England, describes him as a Pennsylvania Quaker who emerged as one of the earliest anti-slavery activists in America. Historian Marcus Rediker, in his book *An Enlightenment Activist: The Singular Fate of Benjamin Lay*, portrays Lay as a prophetic figure who sought to revolutionize the anti-slavery cause through unconventional methods, which Rediker associates with the term “guerrilla theater.”
Lay was disowned by four Quaker meetings, two in England and two in Pennsylvania, according to the Quaker.org.uk report. The La Vie des Idées article says he was eventually renounced by his Quaker community and remained a controversial figure. The sources do not give dates for the individual disownments.
Abington Monthly Meeting in Pennsylvania has taken steps to acknowledge and mitigate its 1738 disownment of Lay, the Quaker.org.uk report states. The report does not describe the specific steps taken or when they were taken. In reporting on the disownment, the Quaker.org.uk article links the meeting’s action to the 1738 decision, and this is the only account of the meeting’s current response in the source material.
Lay’s story has also been presented in other media. Quaker.org.uk reports that the film *Becoming Benjamin Lay* explores the making of a play titled *The Return of Benjamin Lay* and features Rediker and director and actor Mark Povinelli. The film was well received, though some viewers suggested adding subtitles to improve accessibility.
Sources (3):
- A disowned prophet: learning about Benjamin Lay (quaker.org.uk)
- Anti-slavery in the Age of Enlightenment (laviedesidees.fr)
- The "Quaker Comet" Was the Greatest Abolitionist You've Never Heard Of (smithsonianmag.com)
Kingdom News Location
Euston, Eversholt Street, St Pancras, London Borough of Camden, Greater London, England, NW1 2DU, United Kingdom
Open map