
Anglican Schism Reflects Broader Concerns Than Women and LGBTQ Issues, Commentator Argues
In an opinion essay published by Religion Unplugged, the author argues that the division within the Anglican Communion is about more than the ordination of women and questions about LGBTQ inclusion. The author describes the split as a historic schism that has fractured the worldwide Anglican Communion, and says that a simple account of progress against bigotry is inadequate.
The author says the claim that the dispute began because a woman was chosen to lead is mistaken. Writing of the Global South bishops and GAFCON-aligned provinces, the author notes that some of these provinces do not ordain women as bishops, but many do. As an example, the author cites the Anglican Church of Kenya, which consecrated the Right Reverend Dr. Emily Onyango as a bishop in 2021. According to the essay, GAFCON’s leadership issued a letter expressing “regret” that the consecration broke a moratorium, but Kenya remains a core member.
The author states that the objection to Archbishop-elect Sarah Mullally concerns her theology rather than her gender. The essay contends that a conservative or traditionalist woman, such as Jill Duff, the Bishop of Lancaster, whom the author describes as respected, would have drawn a more open response from GAFCON and GSFA bishops. The author characterizes Mullally as a self-described pro-choice feminist and as the chief architect of same-sex blessing liturgies. These descriptions are the author’s own assessments.
The essay also disputes the charge of homophobia against the Global South. It points to Lambeth Resolution I.10 from 1998, which the author says was the standard for the Anglican Communion for more than twenty-five years. According to the author, the resolution upholds the historic definition of marriage, does not permit the blessing of same-sex unions, calls for compassion and love for LGBTQ+ persons, and condemns discrimination and prejudice against them. The author argues that the Church of England, not the Global South, has departed from this consensus.
The author gives historical context for the Ugandan church, stating that it was formed through the deaths of martyrs who were executed for refusing the advances of a pagan king. The essay describes the Global South’s stance as shaped by a worldview that, in the author’s account, lacks the Western category of “sexual orientation” and focuses on homosexual practice. The author acknowledges that inhumane laws against LGBTQ+ people in some member countries are a serious problem, while arguing that the West has not sought to understand this different framework.
Finally, the author assigns the blame for the division to the leadership of the Communion. Citing an earlier article the author co-wrote with a bishop in Baptist News Global two years ago, the essay describes the Church of England’s compromise on same-sex blessings as “disastrous” and a “lose-lose position for everyone.” The author says this approach has left orthodox, non-affirming believers, such as the Communion Partners in The Episcopal Church, isolated, while failing to satisfy progressive activists.
Source: Read the original report