
Augustine Taught Believers to Walk Together in Faith and Doubt
For the bishop of Hippo, walking in faith was a communal activity, and doubt was part of it. Margaret R. Miles, writing in the Christian Century, describes Augustine’s view that doubt is not a threat to belief but a recognition that belief does not amount to knowledge. In summary form, Miles writes, his view might be stated as “I do not know; therefore I believe.”
Miles notes that Augustine’s largest written legacy was his sermons, which she describes as accessible, thoughtful, and empathetic reflections addressed to his congregation in the North African town of Hippo. Possidius, Augustine’s longtime friend and biographer, wrote that those who gained the most from him were those who could see and hear him preach in church. Miles observes that the *Confessions*, Augustine’s midlife autobiography, attracts more current attention, particularly his account of his conversion to celibacy. Miles writes that Augustine did not urge others to expect or seek such an experience.
According to Miles, Augustine’s sermons recommend a lifelong practice of walking together with others as members of the body of Christ, which strengthens what he called the “inner eye.” In a sermon on John 18:1, Augustine said he was walking by faith alongside his hearers, and Miles reports that he shared what had helped him believe rather than relying on instruction or “bishop speak.” Miles writes that Augustine described belief as a “feeling of the mind,” a gift from God that he said cannot be produced by a preacher.
Miles writes that Augustine saw doubt as an important part of walking together in faith. In a sermon on 1 John 4:4–12, Augustine said that if he claimed to tell his listeners what he knew, he would be presumptuous, and he insisted that the fulfillment of belief must be “left to God.” Miles reports that Augustine considered the distinction between belief and knowledge essential for preachers who want to help others believe. Augustine’s own view, as quoted in the *Enchiridion*, was that “we believe, and we believe without any doubt what we admit we cannot know.”
Miles notes that Augustine called the bodily resurrection the “most difficult Christian doctrine” and even described it as unbelievable, acknowledging that it is supported neither by experience nor evidence. In *City of God*, Augustine wrote that it would be rash to describe the resurrection of the dead, yet he said the joy of hope should not be left unspoken. Miles also reports that, as a pastor, Augustine advised grieving people to picture their loved ones as they expected to see them again on the day of resurrection, and that he wrote a letter of comfort to a grieving woman.
Miles writes that Augustine’s sense of human vulnerability, expressed in his repeated remark, “We are so weak,” shaped his understanding of the church as a shared life in which the self is “completed and perfected” rather than absorbed. Miles reports that as Augustine was dying, he asked that the penitential psalms be copied and posted on his walls. In one of his last sermons, Augustine said that he lived for the purpose that all people should live together with Christ, calling this his desire, his honor, his most treasured possession, and his joy, pride, and glory (John 17:21).
Source: Read the original report