
Barker says Unification Church had fewer than 150 members in Britain in 1976, disputing brainwashing claims
Writing in The Guardian in 2012, sociologist Eileen Barker revisited the panic over “cults” in the West during the 1970s and 1980s after the death of Sun Myung Moon, described as about the last surviving charismatic leader of those movements. At the time, it was widely declared that these groups threatened to undermine civilisation by brainwashing young people into becoming zombies prepared to do anything, including mass suicide and murder.
Barker notes that Moon’s Unification Church was one of many groups that drew attention, alongside David Berg’s Children of God, the International Society for Krishna Consciousness, Bhagwan Rajneesh’s sannyasins and L. Ron Hubbard’s Church of Scientology. She writes that the public was largely unaware of how different these groups were. Much of the public’s understanding, she argues, was shaped by sensationalist media and by “anti-cult groups” that began as gatherings of concerned relatives but grew into lobbying organisations. These groups collected the worrying stories about each movement and generalised them into a view of “what all cults do.” Barker adds that such practices can also be found in traditional religions, though this does not make deceptive practices, sexual exploitation or child abuse any less culpable.
The explanation most often heard for why educated young people joined these movements was brainwashing. According to this account, recruits had left universities and promising careers, cut ties with their families, and lived in secluded communities working long hours for their “puppet masters.” Members of the Unification Church were said to have married in mass weddings arranged by a Korean messiah, often to people they had never met. Critics claimed these recruits were victims of irresistible and irreversible mind-control techniques.
Looking back, Barker argues that these views need correcting. Unificationists were highly visible in public, but far fewer people joined than was alleged. Estimates of the number of Unificationists in Britain topped a million, yet there were fewer than 150 in 1976. Thousands attended the residential weekends where brainwashing was said to occur, but Barker reports that 90% did not join as a result, and most of those who did left within a couple of years. In her view, the movements could not have had access to the techniques they were reputed to use. Telling the truth about membership numbers, rather than repeating the most alarming claims, is a matter of honest dealing (Proverbs 11:1).
Barker says that the situation has since changed. Thousands of new religious movements remain active around the world, and Inform, a government-funded organisation, lists more than a thousand active in the UK. Yet most people would struggle to name more than a few. She suggests two reasons: since 9/11, public concern has shifted toward Islamic terrorism rather than cults, and although many people still seek answers about God and spirituality, they are less likely to turn to a new religion for them.
The movements themselves have also changed. Those that drew attention in the latter half of the twentieth century now have second- and even third-generation members who are more concerned with getting on in the outside world than with recruitment. Newer movements tend to be more spiritual and less institutionalised. Most Unificationists now live with their families and work independently of the movement. Barker notes that the second-generation members who have stayed, though a minority, are often married to someone their parents suggested, sometimes with considerable input from their children.
Scientology, Barker writes, may be one of the few “bogey cults” still in the public eye, partly because of the number of high-level members who have recently left and partly because of the high-profile activities of Tom Cruise. She suggests that Paul Thomas Anderson’s film *The Master*, about the origins of Scientology, might add to public understanding of “the cult experience.”
Source: Read the original report