
Council in Lviv, Ukraine, in 1946 ended Greek Catholic union with Rome, according to Russian history site
On 8 March 1946 in Lviv, according to the source, the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church broke its union with Rome and merged with the Russian Orthodox Church. The source places the council itself, the Lviv Cathedral, over 8 to 10 March 1946. It describes the council as ending a long-standing separation from Rome and returning Ukrainian Greek Catholics to Orthodoxy. The source is a Russian history website, and its account is written from that perspective.
The source traces the background to the Union of Brest. It states that the Act of Accession of the Western Russian Orthodox Church to the Roman Catholic Church was signed in Rome on 23 December 1595 and approved in Brest on 19 October 1596. It says that the Greek Catholic communities that resulted kept Byzantine rite services and Slavonic liturgy, and it quotes the priest Gabriel Costelnik, one of the council’s organizers, as saying in 1946 that Rome had never recognized them as true Catholics. The source also says that the union was not accepted by all believers, and it describes an earlier Orthodox mission in 1794 and a 1839 council at Polotsk, which it says brought more than 1.6 million parishioners and more than 1,500 priests back to Orthodoxy.
The source states that the 1946 council was largely initiated by the state. It cites a note by George Karpov, head of the Russian Orthodox Church Council under the Council of People’s Commissars, which it says carried a Stalin resolution. The note, as quoted in the source, described the Roman Catholic Church as a force that had taken the path of defending fascism, and it proposed “activities to separate the parishes of the Greek-Catholic (Uniat) Church in the USSR from the Vatican” and later joining them to the Russian Orthodox Church. The source notes that Costelnik had been a member of a three-member initiative group preparing the council and that he defended the decision in his address to the assembly.
According to the source, the council’s decisions were supported by most of the Greek Catholic clergy, with 997 of 1,270 priests described as fully backing them. The source adds that the common faithful also agreed, and it cites secret state security reports that described popular attitudes toward a return to Orthodoxy as “neutral or positive.” The source reports that concerns were raised before the council that the church’s leadership would be used to the detriment of the faithful, and it says that these concerns were later confirmed when the violent seizure of churches and the dissolution of parishes began. The source does not give dates or details for those later events. Its account of the period reflects a concern for protecting the vulnerable (Psalm 82:3).
The source says that Rome was very negative about the council but did not issue its own statement. It also reports that the Ukrainian Orthodox Church, in 2006, said that the historical circumstances and the Soviet totalitarian context in which the Council of Lviv was held in no way justified it, while still condemning the acts at Brest in 1596 and calling for prayer that the Orthodox faith be affirmed in Ukraine.
Source: Read the original report (translated from Russian)