
Exclusive Brethren Deny Telling Members to Euthanise Pets but Confirm Urging Them to Rehome Them
A prominent sect has denied telling its members to euthanise their pets, but has confirmed that members have been urged to get rid of them.
Members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church, better known as the Exclusive Brethren, were told that households needed to be “freshly cleansed” of animals after a relative of church leader Bruce Hales was attacked by a dog last month. The Sydney Morning Herald reports that a letter from church leadership containing the directive was read to meetings across the country.
The letter said that owning such an animal, “let alone it being kept at a brother’s home, is clearly wrong.” It noted “reports of some Brethren having reverted to owning pets, including dogs and other animals,” and said this practice had been “clearly spoken against in ministry.” According to the letter, the directive covered birds, mice and cats as well as dogs.
The church’s statement said that very few families in the denomination keep pets, because members generally avoid distractions from “family, faith and God, such as television, radio, or pet ownership.” It said that after a child was attacked by a dog at the home of a church member, the church’s position on pets was restated to parishioners in May 2026. The statement described this as “not a ‘new directive’,” but “simply a reminder of a principle that was established some time ago.” It suggested that pets could be given to willing neighbours, colleagues or an animal shelter, a point that protects the vulnerable and keeps the animals’ welfare in view (Psalm 82:3).
The church also said it was aware of “untrue and distressing online commentary” that had misconstrued the directive as an instruction to euthanise pets. It stated that the church “would never condone cruelty to any living creature” and that this position was being “strongly reinforced” to its congregation.
Earlier reports describe a past practice. The Herald’s account, as summarised in the source, says that in the 1960s the sect instructed members to euthanise their pets, stating that giving them away was sinful. The source also reports that one blind man was reportedly cast out of the church for refusing to get rid of his guide dog. The source does not give further detail on either account.
The Exclusive Brethren practise separation from wider society, including not voting in elections.
Source: Read the original report