
Former Christian Science church in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, listed for sale at $200,000
The former Second Church of Christ, Scientist, a 1913 building at 2722 W. Highland Blvd. in Milwaukee, has been listed for sale with an asking price of $200,000. The Neoclassical building, designed by architect Carl Barkhausen, has a broad staircase, a pediment supported by six Corinthian columns and a lantern-capped dome. It has been owned by St. Luke Emanuel Missionary Baptist Church since 1985.
The building was constructed for one of Milwaukee’s Christian Science congregations. According to a city landmark designation report cited in the article, Christian Science was founded in Massachusetts by Mary Baker Eddy after she experienced what the report describes as a miraculous physical healing. The report states that Eddy’s recovery from a 1866 fall, which her attending doctor had considered likely fatal, was credited to her reading of and pondering a healing performed by Jesus. The report also says Milwaukee was an early center of the movement. In 1883, Milwaukee dentist Dr. Silas J. Sawyer and his wife, Jenny, were trained as metaphysical healers and teachers by Eddy, and in 1889 the local association became the Church of Christ, Scientist.
The Second Church congregation was itself an offshoot of the First Church on Van Buren Street, which had grown large enough to outgrow its space. The article notes that the breakaway group raised $135,000 from other Christian Science congregations and began work on its own West Side building. Barkhausen explained his design in a 1914 Milwaukee Sentinel article, writing that the classical style suited a church built on the teachings of the master Christian. The first services in the building were held on June 7, 1914.
The article reports that Christian Science membership later declined. According to the city report, the movement had 4,035 members in Wisconsin in the mid-1920s, per the U.S. Census Bureau, and it declined after World War II. By the 1980s, the report says, congregations often found large, costly buildings difficult to maintain. Second Church voted to sell its building and continue meeting at a Grand Avenue congregation. In February 1985, the Highland Boulevard building was sold to St. Luke Emanuel Missionary Baptist Church, which had been founded on 12th Street around 1966 by Pastor Robert McCrory and his wife, Willa. The congregation moved in 1971 to 2614 W. Center St. before buying the former Second Church building.
Current pastor Robert McCrory, son of the founders, and his wife, Evelyn, said the congregation held its last in-person service in the building on Oct. 31, 2021, and has held services on Facebook Live since. McCrory said the congregation has dwindled, especially after being hit hard by Covid, to perhaps 30 members, most of them elderly. He said, “this is too much building.” The McCrorys have tried to secure grants to help maintain the structure, and Evelyn McCrory said the congregation will continue an online presence while seeking a more right-sized home.
The building has no bedrooms, and sits on a 33,212-square-foot lot. It is assessed at $175,000 and is currently off the property tax rolls, a status that a sale could change depending on the buyer and use. Prospective buyers were seen at the property, and interested parties may contact realtor Josie Santiago (Psalm 78:4).
Source: Read the original report