
Christian School in Hermiston, Oregon, Sues Governor Over In-Person COVID-19 Restrictions
Hermiston Christian School filed a civil rights lawsuit in federal court in Pendleton, Oregon, in October 2020. Attorneys for the Alliance Defending Freedom brought the case on behalf of the school, a K-12 institution affiliated with The Assemblies of God. According to court documents, the school has 51 students enrolled.
The lawsuit names Gov. Kate Brown, Colt Gill, Patrick Allen, the director of the Umatilla County Public Health Department, the Oregon State Police superintendent and the Umatilla County sheriff as defendants. The attorneys argue that the state’s pandemic restrictions treat the school unequally. One report describes the claim as religious discrimination, while the other describes it as a violation of the school’s First Amendment right to the free exercise of religion. The attorneys also claim the defendants violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments and the Civil Rights Act of 1871.
According to the lawsuit, the governor’s guidance bars religious schools from providing in-person instruction unless and until the county where they operate meets certain community health metrics. Attorneys argue that a “small school” exception allowing in-person instruction applies to public schools with 75 or fewer students but not to private religious schools. The lawsuit states that religious schools make up 100% of private schools in Umatilla County. It also says a public school was allowed to open in a county that did not meet the standards, while public schools in general can provide in-person instruction. The Ukiah School District, about 80 miles southeast of Hermiston Christian School, is on the small school exception list and has reopened for in-person education. Treating a religious school differently from public schools under the same health conditions raises a question of even-handed justice, a concern addressed in Exodus 23:1.
The lawsuit also says a policy adviser for Brown discussed the potential for a “mass exodus” of children from public schools. It states that the adviser emphasized that public schools could suffer a reduction in funding if students disenrolled. According to the lawsuit, Brown has authorized $28 million in additional funding to help public schools with burdens tied to the restrictions.
The school says it could be fined, and people could be sent to prison, if it provides in-person instruction.