
Highland Park United Methodist Church Council Says It No Longer Recognizes Conference Authority as Lawsuit Proceeds in Dallas, Texas
The Horizon Texas Conference filed a lawsuit against Highland Park United Methodist Church on August 10 in Dallas County’s state civil court. The suit challenges changes the church council made to the congregation’s articles of incorporation and bylaws in 2022. According to one report, the conference alleges the congregation altered its governing documents without proper consultation. That report says the disputed changes removed most references to the United Methodist Church and the Book of Discipline from the bylaws and articles. Whether the changes were made properly is the central question in the dispute, a matter of honest dealing with the documents that govern the church (Proverbs 11:1).
In response, the church council unanimously passed a resolution describing the conference’s lawsuit as a “profound betrayal.” The resolution states that the church “no longer recognizes the ecclesiastical authority of the bishop and conference to direct the Church or its Clergy.” Two UMNews.org reports carry the same resolution language, and both date it to 2022.
A later UMNews.org report, dated August 2025, describes a further hardening of the council’s position. It says the council unanimously approved a resolution declaring that the church does not recognize the ecclesiastical authority of the bishop or the conference to lead the church or its clergy. That report quotes the council calling the legal action a “profound treachony” aimed at protecting its clergy from “punitive measures.” The reports differ in their dating and wording of the council’s stance, so the 2022 and 2025 accounts should be read as separate versions.
Dallas News reported that church leadership asked members, during a town hall meeting, to consider leaving the United Methodist Church following the legal dispute with the denomination. According to that report, no final decision has been made.
Highland Park United Methodist Church also released a statement on the lawsuit. The version available in the source material is incomplete and does not include the statement’s full text, so its contents cannot be reported here.
Sources (7):
- Highland Park leaders escalate response to lawsuit | UMNews.org (umnews.org)
- Highland Park leaders escalate response to lawsuit | UMNews.org (umnews.org)
- Highland Park pastors, conference address suit | UMNews.org (umnews.org)
- IMU Highland Park leaders harden their stand on the lawsuit UMNews.org (umnews.org)
- Highland Park UMC asks members to consider possibility of leaving UMC (dallasnews.com)
- Read the documents in the legal dispute between Highland Park UMC and United Methodist Church (yahoo.com)
- Read Highland Park UMC's full statement on United Methodist Church lawsuit (dallasnews.com)