
Highland Park Methodist Church Asks Court in Dallas, Texas, to Block UMC Conference From Using Its Name
The United Methodist Church of Highland Park in Dallas voted in an October 25-26 election to leave the United Methodist Church, according to The New York Times. The vote was held in person and supervised by a third-party administrator, Election Trust. Of 4,775 votes cast, just over 90 percent favored leaving, according to The Times.
Days later, on October 29, the head of the UMC’s Horizon Texas Conference announced that the church remains part of the United Methodist Church and appointed a new chief pastor, according to CBS News.
The congregation, which dropped “United” from its name and holds services at its own building at Hillcrest Road and Mockingbird Lane, later asked a court for a temporary restraining order against the Horizon Texas Conference. The church seeks to stop the conference from using the name Highland Park United Methodist Church (HPUMC) in holding services. The church claims the name belongs to it after more than 50 years of use, and says the conference is infringing on that use. According to the church, members and donors have been unsure which of the two churches’ services they attended, a concern that bears on clear and honest identification in a dispute of this kind (Ephesians 4:15). Sight Magazine reported that the church filed the restraining order the previous week and described the congregation as the largest in the UMC fold.
Christian Post reported that the church is also fighting a lawsuit from the Horizon Texas Conference over changes its leaders made to the church’s governing documents. The reports differ on the church’s current status. Sight Magazine said members voted last month to leave the denomination, and the earlier account from The Times and CBS described the October vote as a decision to leave, while the conference said the church remains part of the UMC.
On Sunday, October 11, 2026, the church held a town hall meeting to discuss possibly leaving the mainline Protestant denomination, according to Christian Post. Caroline Nowlin, chair of the HPUMC Church Council, said the council had not decided whether the church should remain part of the United Methodist Church. She said that if the council recommended leaving, the decision would go to a congregational vote.
Sight Magazine’s report names Bishop Ruben Saenz, Jr., of the Horizon Texas Conference, but the material available does not include what he said.
Sources (4):
- Highland Park Methodist Church asks court to block UMC conference from using its former name (christianpost.com)
- In the US, Dallas' Highland Park church sues the UMC over rights to its name – Sight Magazine (sightmagazine.com.au)
- Highland Park Church voted to leave the United Methodist Church. (fr.qz.com)
- Texas megachurch may leave UMC amid ongoing legal battle with conference (christianpost.com)